What’s The Safest Car Seat For A 2-Year-Old?
Car seats can protect your 2-year-old, reducing fatal injury risks by as much as 71%. That’s vital because, in the US, motor vehicle accidents are the top 2 most common cause of death for kids ages 1-4 years old. As much as 27% of these fatal accidents involved kids without car seats. (1)(2)(3)
We all want to find the best car seat for utmost protection. Does that mean you should choose the most expensive, highest-rated car seat for your 2-year-old?
Well, not necessarily. According to the NHTSA (National Highway Traffic Safety Administration), a higher car safety rating doesn’t always mean the car seat is safer and better. Instead, a “properly chosen and installed car seat” offers the most effective protection. (4)
Choosing the right car seat is key to your child’s safety. It must be suitable for their age and pass the safety standards. More importantly, it must be installed properly, with your child securely strapped in.
Aside from age recommendations, what other factors should you consider when choosing your 2-year-old’s car seat? What safety features must you check?
We’ll answer these questions below, including our top 7 recommendations for proven, non-toxic, and durable car seats suitable for your 2-year-old.
What Car Seat Should A 2-Year-Old Be In?
Your 2-year-old can use both rear and forward-facing car seats. However, the NHTSA recommends keeping kids in a rear-facing car seat for as long as possible.
Most kids outgrow the infant car seat before their first birthday. Toddler car seats suitable for your 2-year-old include forward-facing, convertible, and all-in-one options.
Types Of Car Seats & When To Use Them
- Infant car seat: Birth to one year old
- Rear-facing car seat: Birth to three years old
- Forward-facing harness seat: 1-7 years old
- Convertible (rear-facing & forward-facing) car seat: Birth or 1 year to 7 years old
- All-in-one car seat (convertible + booster): Birth to 12 years old
- Booster car seat (e.g., backless, high back, and/or belt-positioning): 4-12 years old
How Long Can A 2-Year-Old Use A Car Seat?
Your 2-year-old will always need to be in a car seat. They can use a booster seat once they turn 4 years old. (5)
Can A 2-Year-Old Use A Forward-Facing Car Seat?
Yes. Technically, a 2-year-old can already be in a forward-facing car seat. But it’s best to keep them in a rear-facing seat up to the manufacturer’s recommended height and weight limits. (5)
Should A 2-Year-Old Be Rear-Facing?
If possible, yes. The AAP (American Academy of Pediatrics) and NHTSA recommend using the rear-facing seat for as long as possible. (3)(5)
What Is The Weight Limit For A 2-Year-Old Car Seat?
Different car seat brands and products have varied height and weight limits. Many convertible car seats can be used until your child weighs 40-50 lbs. Others can be used until 65-100+ lbs but converted into a booster seat.
Always check your car seat’s specifications (printed on the label) to ensure your child doesn’t exceed the limits.
Can A 2-Year-Old Still Use An Infant Seat?
No. Infant car seats are specifically made for babies. Your child is likely to outgrow it before they turn one year old. However, convertible and all-in-one car seats can be used by infants, toddlers, preschoolers, and even grade schoolers up to 12 years old. (5)
Can A 2-Year-Old Use A Booster Car Seat?
No. Booster seats are designed for kids who are at least 4 years old. The NHTSA even recommends waiting until your child outgrows the forward-facing car seat‘s weight and/or height limits before using a booster seat. (5)
What Car Seat Should Preemies Use?
Car seats for infants weighing at least 3-4 lbs can be suitable for preemies. Check that the infant insert is as flat as possible. Bulky padding can make your preemie’s head pitch forward, posing suffocation risks. (6)
Options can include the following:
- Evenflo LiteMax 35 Infant Car Seat – 4 to 35 lbs
- NUNA REVV Rotating Car Seat – 4 to 32 lbs
- Graco Extend2Fit 3-in-1 Car Seat – 4 to 65 lbs
- Diono Radian 3QXT All-In-One Seat – 4 to 65 lbs
- Maxi-Cosi Pria All-In-One Convertible Car Seat – 4 to 65 lbs
These car seats can grow with your preemie and are also suitable for 2-year-olds.
Our Top 7 Car Seat Recommendations: Key Points
Convertible Car Seats
- UPPAbaby Knox Convertible Car Seat (1-6 years old) – Koroyd technology used in the base (crumple zone that can effectively protect your child from the dangers of impact forces in a crash); hypoallergenic Merino wool covers are also available
- Cybex Sirona S With SensorSafe Convertible Car Seat (newborn to 4 years old) – America’s first 360° rotatable seat, with an EasyLock rebound bar, 12-position headrest, and a smart SensorSafe system that alerts you (via app) when your child unbuckles their seat belt
- Nuna REVV 360-Degree Rotating Car Seat (newborn to 40 lbs) – GREENGUARD GOLD certified (with low chemical emissions, particularly for 360+ toxic volatile organic compounds or VOCs and other dangerous materials), GOTS (Global Organic Textile Standard) organic cotton fabrics, steel-reinforced True lock base, and spins 360 degrees
- Evenflo Gold Revolve360 Extend Green & Gentle All-in-One Rotational Car Seat (newborn to 5+ years old) – 360-degree rotating car seat with extended use in the rear-facing position (up to 50 lbs), special “Green & Gentle” flame retardant-free fabric, SensorSafe system, several color combinations (for the fabrics), and real-time installation guidance via customer support
Front-Facing Car Seats
- Chicco MyFit Zip Air Harness + Booster Seat (2+ years old) – Among the narrowest car and booster seats (17.5” wide), with an easy zip-off design for quick and easy seat cover removal or replacement, and a contoured ErgoBoost seat with a padded waist belt padding
All-In-One Car Seats
- Safety 1st Grow & Go All-in-One Convertible Car Seat (newborn to 4+ years old) – Budget-friendly 3-in-1 car seat for long-term use up to 10 years that meets quality and safety standards
- Graco Premier 4Ever DLX Extend2Fit SnugLock 4-in-1 Car Seat (newborn to 10 years old) – 4-in-1 car seat your child can use from newborn to 10 years old, with additional legroom of up to 5” to let your child ride longer using the rear-facing mode
Continue reading for more detailed information about these car seats for 2-year-olds.
Convertible Car Seats
UPPAbaby Knox Convertible Car Seat (1-6 years old)
Top Reasons To Buy
- Available in two different fabric options: original (free from fire retardants) and naturally fire-resistant models with hypoallergenic, temperature-regulated Merino wool
- Uses Koroyd technology in the base (with a crumple zone that helps protect your child from impact forces during a crash)
Pros: What Makes It Special?
- Conversion Options: With rear-facing and forward-facing modes; plus an eight-position headrest
- Age Range: From 1-6 years old
- Child Weight Capacity: From 14 to 45 lbs using the rear-facing mode (14-25 lbs if you’re using the infant insert) and from 25 to 65 lbs using the forward-facing mode
- Child Height Capacity: Up to 49”
Safety Features
- Free from toxic fire-retardant chemicals
- Base uses smart Koroyd technology, which creates a crumple zone (can effectively protect from the dangers of impact forces, such as in a crash)
- Impact-absorbing and flame-resistant materials meet safety standards
- Multi-directional tether (works with the rear and forward-facing configurations) reduces seat rotation and impact stress (during a crash) to your child’s head and neck
- Side impact pods provide additional impact absorption
- Reinforced belt path
- No-rethread, five-point harness
Key Features
- Material: Steel frame, fabrics free from fire retardants, and foam (inner material)
- Ease Of Installation: SMARTSECURE System for a secure and easy installation; includes visual guides and bead level indicators on both sides), robust tensioning clips, and color-coded belt paths (help reduce possible user error)
Other features:
- Adjustable active support headrest that grows with your child
- Adjustable, multi-position foot support (for ample legroom and leveling)
- Removable machine-washable seat fabrics
- Removable cup holders
Other Specifications
- Warranty: Two years (limited lifetime warranty for seats purchased after January 1, 2019; must register the product online within three months of purchase)
- Weight: 39.4 lbs (according to Amazon)
- Dimensions: 23.8” L x 18.8” W x 27.4 to 32.5” H (headrest in the lowest and highest positions)
- Extra Features: Storage pockets to tuck harness buckles when unused
- Expiration: Check the label on the car seat’s base for its actual expiration date
Product Recall
No UPPAbaby recall has been officially issued for the Knox car seat. (7)
However, in 2021, UPPAbaby messaged registered Knox Convertible Child seat (2020 model) buyers to quit using the product due to a possible manufacturing or design defect. Even with secured installation, the defective product can move, possibly compromising the user’s safety. (7)
UPPAbaby didn’t issue an official recall. However, the NHTSA’s investigation showed that the manufacturer warned buyers that continued use of the affected car seats would be at their own risk. (7)
According to the NHTSA, UPPAbaby also sent a letter with instructions on how their customers can do the following: (7)
- Disable the affected car seat to prevent further use
- Process a full refund plus a $50 incentive for the possibly defective seat
No injuries or fatalities were reported for the UPPAbaby Knox issue. (7)
Cons & Drawbacks
- Can be pricey
- The 2020 model had a possible defect
- Some customer complaints about shrinking fabric (even if they followed the manufacturer’s cleaning instructions)
What Customers Say
Positive Reviews
“Despite the weight this car seat isn’t too difficult to install. I appreciate the low tox elements and the reclining feature…” – Reviewer on Amazon
Negative Reviews
“The straps get so twisted on this car seat… so easily. The black parts that “fit” into the back don’t stay in place and always come forward when we loosen the straps…” – Reviewer on UPPAbaby
Cybex Sirona S With SensorSafe Convertible Car Seat (newborn to 4 years old)
Top Reasons To Buy
- America’s first 360° rotatable seat
- Includes a smart SensorSafe system that alerts you (via app) when your child unbuckles their seat belt
- Has an EasyLock rebound bar
Pros: What Makes It Special?
- Conversion Options: Rear facing to front facing, with 360° rotation and adjustable headrest with 12 positions
- Age Range: Newborn to 4 years old
- Child Weight Capacity: From 4 lbs up to 65 lbs
- Child Height Capacity: 17” to 49” (child’s head must be at least 1” from the top)
Safety Features
- SensorSafe system (detects unbuckled child)
- Leg EasyLock Bar
- One-time vehicle belt installation
- Linear side-impact protection
- Anti-rebound bar
- Free from fire-retardant chemicals
Key Features
- Material: Metal, foam, and polyester fabric
- Ease Of Installation: Easy to install using LATCH system or vehicle’s seat belt
Other features:
- Removable, machine-washable seat pads
- Includes cup holders
Other Specifications
- Warranty: Not indicated
- Weight: 30.4 lbs (according to Amazon)
- Dimensions: 24.5” x 19” x 25.5”
- Extra Features: With magnetic buckle holders
- Expiration: Check the label (found on the car seat’s bottom) for the actual expiration date
Product Recall
- None
Cons & Drawbacks
- Some customer complaints about the car seat being wobbly and difficult to install
What Customers Say
Positive Reviews
“It was a bit of a pain to install, but once it’s in .. zero issues. My 6 and 7 year old can move it and adjust it as easy as I do and I didn’t even have to show them.” – Reviewer on Amazon
Negative Reviews
“Not sturdy enough, it is super wobbly i followed the instructions and everything is green but the chair moves a lot at least facing rear.” – Reviewer on CYBEX
Nuna REVV 360-Degree Rotating Car Seat (newborn to 2+ years old)
Top Reasons To Buy
- GREENGUARD GOLD certified
- Spins 360 degrees
- GOTS organic cotton fabrics
- 5-second steel-reinforced True lock base
Pros: What Makes It Special?
- Conversion Options: Rear-facing and forward-facing positions; includes 10 recline positions
- Age Range: newborn to 2+ years old
- Child Weight Capacity: Up to 4 to 32 lbs
- Child Height Capacity: Up to 32 inches
Safety Features
- GREENGUARD GOLD certified product
- Flame-resistant fabrics that meet the safety standards without using toxic fire-retardant chemicals
- 5-second steel-reinforced True lock base (with a crumple zone in the car seat’s stability leg)
- Integrated rebound bar for added protection
- No-rethread five-point harness
- Side-impact protection
- Ventilation panels
Key Features
- Material: All-steel frame, GOTS organic cotton (for infant head and body inserts), top-of-the-line plastic, and micro-knit fabrics
- Ease Of Installation: Easy with the RELX base installation (includes colored indicators) and seat belt path
Other features:
- Two dishwasher-safe cup holders
- Integrated magnetic buckle holders
Other Specifications
- Warranty: Two years
- Weight: 29.7 lbs
- Dimensions: 31-34” x 18.5” x 19.5-22” (rear-facing position) and 21.5-22.5” x 18.5” x 22.5-29.5” (forward-facing position)
- Extra Features:
- Expiration: Seven years; make sure to check your car seat for the actual expiration date
Product Recall
- None
Cons & Drawbacks
- Can be pricey
- Some customer complaints about the low weight limit and safety issues (becoming wobbly over time)
What Customers Say
Positive Reviews
“This is hands down the best car seat! My son is so comfortable in it and it makes getting him in and out of the car so simple.” – Reviewer on Crate & Barrel
Negative Reviews
“…Seems to wobble more over time as well. Just does not seem as sturdy as other Nuna products.” – Reviewer on Albee Baby
Evenflo Gold Revolve360 Extend Green & Gentle All-in-One Rotational Car Seat (newborn to 5+ years old)
Top Reasons To Buy
- Extended use with the rear-facing position (up to 50 lbs)
- Special “Green & Gentle” flame retardant-free fabric
- Several color combinations available
- Offers real-time installation guidance via customer support
- SensorSafe system
Pros: What Makes It Special?
- Conversion Options: Rear-facing, forward-facing, and high-back booster
- Age Range: Newborn to 5+ years old
- Child Weight Capacity: From 4 to 50 lbs using the rear-facing mode; from 25 to 65 lbs using the forward-facing mode; and from 40 to 120 lbs for the high-back booster seat
- Child Height Capacity: From 17-48” using the rear-facing mode; 28-49” using the forward-facing mode; and 44-57” using the high-back booster seat
Safety Features
- Zip-on, ergonomic, and reversible leg rest
- Extended rear-facing mode
- Uses SensorSafe system that detects if your child accidentally unbuckles their harness
Key Features
- Material: Steel-reinforced frame, foam padding, and fabrics
- Ease Of Installation: Easy to install with LATCH or seat belt installation
Other Specifications
- Warranty: Limited 90-day warranty
- Weight: 31 lbs
- Dimensions: 19.8” x 25.9” x 21.0”
- Extra Features: Removable, machine-washable “quick-clean” seat cover
- Expiration: Not indicated; check your car seat’s label for the actual expiration date
Product Recall
- None
Cons & Drawbacks
- Short warranty period (only for 90 days)
- Some customer complaints about design and safety issues (e.g., short crotch straps and wobbly or shaky seat)
What Customers Say
Positive Reviews
“My favorite feature is the sensor on the clip, and the fact that it revolves however you need it” – Reviewer on Amazon
Negative Reviews
“The straps are floppy and are prone to twisting and getting stuck under my baby.” – Reviewer on Evenflo
Front-Facing Car Seats
Chicco MyFit Zip Air Harness + Booster Seat (2+ years old)
Top Reasons To Buy
- Among the narrowest car and booster seats
- Easy zip-off design for quick and easy seat cover removal or replacement
- Contoured ErgoBoost seat with a padded waist belt and dual-density foam padding
Pros: What Makes It Special?
- Conversion Options: Front-facing 5-point harness car seat and belt-positioning booster; with nine headrest positions, two crotch positions, and four recline positions
- Age Range: At least two years old (harness mode); at least four years old (booster mode)
- Child Weight Capacity: 25 to 65 lbs (harness mode); 40 to 100 lbs (booster mode)
- Child Height Capacity: Up to 54” tall (harness mode); from 38” to 57” tall (booster mode)
Safety Features
- DuoGuard with two layers of protection: rigid, reinforced steel frame with energy-absorbing EPS (expanded polystyrene) foam
- Free from brominated or chlorinated fire retardant chemicals, BPA (bisphenol-A), PFAS (per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances), or phthalates
- 5-point padded, no-rethread safety harness (for use in forward-facing mode)
- Breathable backrest (ventilation)
- LockSure belt-tightening system and SuperCinch tightener
- ReclineSure leveling system
- RideRight bubble levels (for verifying installation angle)
Key Features
- Material: Steel, EPS foam, plastic, and 100% polyester fabric
- Ease Of Installation: Easy to install using LATCH and seat belt lock-off, with leveling system, belt-tightening system, and SuperCinch tightener
Other extra features:
- Easy zip-off design for quick seat cover removal or replacement
- Space-saving, dishwasher-safe cup holders (they can fold out of the way when not in use)
- Bonus storage console
Other Specifications
- Warranty: Not indicated; consumers are instructed to message the company (chiccousa.com/contactus) for warranty questions
- Weight: 26 lbs
- Dimensions: 21” x 17.5” x 26”
- Extra Features: Machine-washable, easy-to-remove seat pads
- Expiration: Not indicated; check your car seat’s label on the base for the actual expiration date
Product Recall
- None
Cons & Drawbacks
- Can be pricey
- Some customer complaints about design and safety issues (e.g., painful shoulder straps, falling apart after a few months, being smaller than expected, and a big button that kids might easily release on the road)
What Customers Say
Positive Reviews
“The material has the best air circulation and the installation is simple!” – Reviewer on Chicco USA
Negative Reviews
“Love this car seat at first, however my 3 year old granddaughter figured out how to push the orange strap release button and loosen the harness herself. This is a safety issue for me.” – Reviewer on Amazon
All-In-One Car Seats
Safety 1st Grow & Go All-in-One Convertible Car Seat (newborn to 10 years old)
Top Reasons To Buy
- Long-term use up to 10 years
Pros: What Makes It Special?
- Conversion Options: With rear-facing and forward-facing modes; also includes an adjustable headrest and a three-position incline
- Age Range: Birth up to 10 years
- Child Weight Capacity: 5-40 lbs (rear facing), 22-65 lbs (forward facing), and 40-100 lbs (belt-positioning booster)
- Child Height Capacity: 19” to 40” (rear facing), 34.4” to 49” (forward facing), and 43.4” to 52” (belt-positioning booster)
Safety Features
- Side impact protection
- Adjustable, no-rethread harness and crotch strap to help you get the right fit for your growing kid
- IIHS (Insurance Institute for Highway Safety) Good Bet rating (in booster mode)
Key Features
- Material: Metal, foam, and fabrics
- Ease Of Installation: Easy installation with belt and LATCH system
Other features:
- Machine-washable, dryer-safe seat pads
- Two removable, dishwasher-safe cup holders
Other Specifications
- Warranty: One year from purchase date
- Weight: 18.6 lbs (according to Amazon)
- Dimensions: 31.75” x 19.25” x 28.75” (according to Amazon)
- Extra Features: Includes harness holders
- Expiration: Not indicated
Product Recall
- Not included in the Safety 1st car seat recall (2023)
Cons & Drawbacks
- Some customer complaints about safety issues (e.g., unsecured installation with the seat moving several inches even if they installed it properly)
What Customers Say
Positive Reviews
“The cushions and texture of the interior of the car seat are luxurious to the touch and EASY TO CLEAN, even the shoulder straps. The material repels liquids and makes for fast cleanup. The cover comes off and goes on easily for washing.” – Reviewer on Dorel Juvenile
Negative Reviews
“ It was impossible to cinch the seat down tight enough that it wouldn’t move. My husband pulled on the belt as hard as he could while I pushed down on the seat, but no matter what we did, the seat would move at least 4 inches side-to-side when we tested it.” – Reviewer on Amazon
Graco Premier 4Ever DLX Extend2Fit SnugLock 4-in-1 Car Seat (newborn to 10 years old)
Top Reasons To Buy
- 4-in-1 car seat your child can use from newborn to 10 years old
- Extend2Fit adjustable extension panel (with four positions) for additional legroom of up to 5” to let your child ride longer using the rear-facing mode
Pros: What Makes It Special?
- Conversion Options: Rear-facing, front-facing, high-back belt-positioning booster, and backless booster with 10 headrest positions and six recline positions
- Age Range: Newborn to 10 years old
- Child Weight Capacity: 4-50 lbs (rear-facing position), 22-65 lbs (forward-facing position), 40-100 lbs (high-back belt-positioning), and 40-120 lbs (backless booster)
- Child Height Capacity: At least 1” below the handle (rear-facing position), up to 49” (forward-facing position), 43-57” (high-back belt-positioning), and 43-57” (backless booster)
Safety Features
- Anti-rebound bar
- Graco ProtectPlus Engineered (passes rigorous crash tests for frontal, rear, side, or rollover crashes)
- EPS energy-absorbing foam
- No-Rethread Simply Safe Adjust Harness System (one motion harness and headrest adjustments)
- InRight LATCH harness and easy LATCH attachment (with audible click to show that the seat has been properly secured)
- Steel-reinforced frame (Graco claims this helps keep the car seat’s durability and strength for up to 10 years of use)
- Passes Graco’s European-based RollSafe testing standards (for rollovers)
- 5-point harness system
- Rear-impact tested (passes the European Rear-Impact Crash Pulse)
- Side-impact protection
- Meets about twice the impact force requirement under the US FMVSS 213 (car seat safety standards)
Key Features
- Material: Steel, plastic, EPS foam, and fabric
- Ease Of Installation: Easy to install, with SnugLock Technology and options for LATCH or belt installation
Other features:
- Rubberized, no-slip grip harness storage pockets
- Easy-to-clean cup holders
Other Specifications
- Warranty: One year
- Weight: 28.1 lbs
- Dimensions: 23.5” x 19” x 28.5”
- Extra Features: Rapid-remove, machine-washable cover (removes in 60 seconds without removing the harness straps or uninstalling the seat)
- Expiration: 10 years from manufacturing date; check your product’s label for the actual date
Product Recall
- None
Cons & Drawbacks
- Some customer complaints about the buckle being too tight and hurting their children’s skin and the padding being too thick that it pushed their baby’s head forward
What Customers Say
Positive Reviews
“We are using it rear facing, & so far, the straps are easy to adjust. The buckle is not too small, & I am able to unclasp it with one hand. It is easy to get baby in & out of it.” – Reviewer on Amazon
Negative Reviews
“I hate that car seat it’s not safe for my baby .it’s hurt her legs so bad , I can’t buckle up the bottom.” – Reviewer on Graco
Summary & Recommendations
Choosing a car seat that suits your 2-year-old’s needs, weight, and height is ideal. Consider these recommendations:
Convertible Car Seats
Choose UPPAbaby Knox Convertible Car Seat (1-6 years old) if you:
- Prefer a car seat that uses Koroyd technology used in the base (crumple zone that can effectively protect your child from the dangers of impact forces in a crash)
- Want an option for hypoallergenic Merino wool cover
- Don’t mind that it previously had a safety issue (already resolved)
Choose Cybex Sirona S With SensorSafe Convertible Car Seat (newborn to 4 years old) if you:
- Prefer America’s first 360° rotatable seat
- Want a car seat with an EasyLock rebound bar
- Like that it has a 12-position headrest
- Love the peace of mind of having a smart SensorSafe system that sends an alert when your child unbuckles their seat belt
Choose Nuna REVV 360-Degree Rotating Car Seat (newborn to 40 lbs) if you:
- Want peace of mind with a GREENGUARD GOLD certified car seat with low chemical emissions (checked for 360+ toxic volatile organic compounds and other dangerous materials)
- Like having GOTS (Global Organic Textile Standard) organic cotton fabrics
- Prefer a car seat with a steel-reinforced True lock base
- Like that it spins 360 degrees to easily put your child in or take them out of the seat
- Don’t mind the price tag
Choose Evenflo Gold Revolve360 Extend Green & Gentle All-in-One Rotational Car Seat (newborn to 5+ years old) if you:
- Like a 360-degree rotating car seat with extended use in the rear-facing position (up to 50 lbs)
- Prefer a car seat with cleaner materials (made from Evenflo’s special “Green & Gentle” flame retardant-free fabric)
- Want different color combinations (for the fabrics) to choose from
- Love that it has a SensorSafe system
- Prefer a brand that offers real-time installation guidance via customer support
Front-Facing Car Seats
Choose Chicco MyFit Zip Air Harness + Booster Seat (2+ years old) if you:
- Prefer a narrow car seat (17.5” wide)
- Want one with easy zip-off design for quick and easy seat cover removal or replacement
- Like a contoured ErgoBoost seat with a padded waist belt padding
- Don’t mind that you can use it as an infant car seat
All-In-One Car Seats
Choose Safety 1st Grow & Go All-in-One Convertible Car Seat (newborn to 4+ years old) if you:
- Want a 3-in-1 car seat for long-term use up to 10 years
- Prefer a budget-friendly car seat that meets quality and safety standards
Choose Graco Premier 4Ever DLX Extend2Fit SnugLock 4-in-1 Car Seat (newborn to 10 years old) if you:
- Prefer a 4-in-1 car seat your child can use from newborn to 10 years old
- Like that it has additional legroom of up to 5” so your child can ride longer using the rear-facing mode
Car Seat Safety Reminders
Never use the following car seats:
- Not intended for your child’s age, height, or weight
- Involved in a moderate or severe crash
- Recalled car seat
- Looks old
- Has missing parts
- No labels or instructions
Replacing Car Seats After An Accident
A car seat’s safety features might be compromised after a moderate or severe crash. They could be inadequate in protecting your child in another accident. (8)
So, the NHTSA recommends replacing all car seats after a moderate and/or severe crash. You must do it even if it looks okay. Car seats don’t need to be replaced after a minor crash, but only if all of these situations apply: (8)
- The car still worked and was driven away from the crash site.
- The door closest to the car seat wasn’t damaged.
- The airbags didn’t deploy during the crash.
- None of the car’s passengers were injured.
- There aren’t any visible damage to the car seat.
However, different car seat brands have varied policies about product replacement after an accident. Many car brands follow the NHTSA’s recommendations.
The following brands suggest replacement even after a minor accident:
- UPPAbaby
- Graco
- Maxi-Cosi (also offers car seat replacement)
- Chicco
- Baby Jogger
- Baby Trend
- Clek
- Cosco
- Safety 1st
- Evenflo (also offers car seat replacement for those with the Evenflo Gold Lifetime Warranty)
- Cybex
- Peg Perego
Diono recommends following the NHTSA guidelines but also offers car seat replacement for their products that were involved in an accident.
Also, check with your insurance company to see if they cover car seat replacement after a crash.
Factors To Help You Choose The Ideal Car Seat For 2-Year-Olds
Product Safety
Car seat safety features must always be the priority when choosing the most suitable restraint for your little one. Here are some safety tips to consider:
Safety Standard: GREENGUARD GOLD Certification
GREENGUARD GOLD Certified products have low chemical emissions, including VOCs (volatile organic compounds) and other potentially toxic or harmful chemicals.
These products might cost more than regular car seats without certification, but they’re certified to be safer for little ones.
You can also read and bookmark Motherhood Community’s Health and Safety Philosophy to learn about possibly toxic chemicals in baby products and how to avoid or reduce your baby’s exposure.
Check The Harness
Adjustable and padded harness straps can help your toddler feel more comfortable while safely secured in their car seat.
Cost & Value For Money (But Don’t Rely On Price Alone)
Pricier doesn’t always mean safer or better. Find a product that suits your budget. It must also meet high safety and quality standards.
Convenience, Extra Features, Durability, & Convertibility
Consider what features you want to have in your child’s car seat. Some of these include:
- Possible safety features (e.g., side impact protection, stability support, reinforced frame, etc.)
- Installation features (e.g., seat belt guide, color indicators, leveling bubbles, etc.)
- Convertibility (i.e., rear-facing, front-facing, and/or booster seat mode)
- Minimum and maximum weight and height limits
- Adjustable leg extenders
- Removable and machine-washable covers
- Extra features (e.g., cup holders, storage pockets, harness storage, etc.)
- Warranty
- Seat expiry
Not all brands allow car seat protectors. So, check the brand’s manufacturer’s recommendations before buying and using one under your car seat. If the car seat manufacturer prohibits or doesn’t recommend their use, using one can void your warranty or affect insurance claims.
Maintenance & Cleaning
Spills, dust accumulation, and blowouts can happen, creating hygiene issues. We recommend choosing car seats with removable, machine-washable seat covers to make cleaning easier.
Product Weight & Dimensions
Consider your vehicle size, the number of seats needed, and the seat configuration (front or rear-facing) versus the car seat’s dimensions and features. Here are some tips:
- Lighter car seats are more suitable for traveling or regularly moving between your vehicles
- Narrower car seats (less than 19” in width) are better for a three-across configuration (however, check your vehicle’s seats for sections that might prevent or affect this configuration, such as bulky padding in middle seats)
Ease Of Installation
Motherhood Community, the NHTSA, AAP, and CDC recommend proper car seat installation to maximize your child’s safety and comfort.
Consider easy-install car seats to ensure you get it right. Some brands offer the following installation features:
- Color indicators or installation guides
- Level indicators
- Audible clicks
Consider Customer Reviews
Learn from other parents’ experiences by reading customer reviews before buying a car seat. Watch out for the following red flags:
- Safety issues (e.g., the buckles broke easily, the straps snapped, etc.)
- Quality issues (e.g., the cover was easily torn, the plastic parts got broken easily, etc.)
- Installation concerns (e.g., installation guides weren’t provided, the product was difficult to install, etc.)
- Concerns about using the product (e.g., wobbly seat, buckles to clip on or release are difficult to access, etc.)
Watch Out For Recalled Car Seats
Some recent car seat recalls:
- Cybex recall (2023)
- Maxi Cosi recalls (2023)
- Safety 1st recalls (2023)
- Baby Trend stroller & car seat recalls (2022)
- UPPAbaby stroller & car seat recalls (2022)
- Maxi Cosi Pria 85 recall (2021)
You can swap unused car seats (even expired recalled products) at the Target Car Seat Trade-In Program. This 2-week event is often scheduled around April and September). You get a 20% off coupon to buy baby essentials (can be used for in-store or online purchases).
Watch Out For Damaged Or Expired Car Seats
Car seats can be damaged from a car crash or through wear and tear. Consider choosing a car seat with proven durability or a longer expiration and/or warranty period.
Is It Okay To Buy A Second-Hand Car Seat?
Probably not a good idea. When buying second-hand, you can’t always tell if the car seat is still safe for use. It might be hard to tell whether the product has been involved in a crash if there isn’t visible damage.
FAQs
Can My 2-Year-Old Use The Car’s Seat Belt?
No. Kids must always be in a car seat from 0 to 7 years old. They can start using an appropriate booster seat when they’re at least 4 years old.
How Do I Ensure My Toddler Feels Comfortable In Their Car Seat?
- The car seat must suit their age, height, and weight.
- Car seats with thicker, plushier material can be more comfortable. However, they should also check for ventilation, as the thicker padding might make the seat warm and uncomfortable on long journeys.
- Check that the harnesses are snug but not too tight. Padded harness straps are a good idea.
Are There Rules For Clothes Type To Wear In Car Seats?
Thick clothes (e.g., puffy jackets) can prevent the harness from snugly securing your child in their car seat. Remove these before strapping your child in. If your child feels cold, you can put a blanket or jacket over the seat.
What To Do If My 2-Year-Old Slouches In Their Car Seat?
You can place a tightly rolled cloth (e.g., a small towel) or diaper on each side of your baby. However, never place anything or use inserts behind their back. (9)
When Do You Stop Using The Car Seat’s 5-Point Harness?
For maximum protection, keeping your child in a car seat with a 5-point harness for as long as possible is best. (9)
What If There Are More Kids In The Vehicle Than Available Car Seats?
Travel only with kids 0 to 7 years old when you have enough car seats for each one. Kids 8+ years old can be in the back seat, but must wear a seat belt.
Should I Buy Products Marketed For Better Seat Belt Fit?
It’s probably not a good idea. Only use products that come with your car seat. Many car seat manufacturers don’t recommend using additional accessories, and your warranty might be voided if you do.
Traveling With A 2-Year-Old
What’s The 2-Hour Limit For Car Seats?
If possible, limit car seat use to 2 hours at a time. Extended use can lead to breathing difficulties and discomfort, especially for younger children. For long trips, consider taking breaks every 2 hours. (10)
Travel Car Seats
Traveling can be safer if you bring a car seat for your kids. Some tips to consider:
- Lighter and slimmer car seats are easier to bring along.
- If you’re flying, check whether your car seat is FAA-approved (Federal Aviation Administration).
Proper Car Seat Installation
Proper seat installation is essential to ensure that the product can provide optimal protection for your child, no matter the situation.
We recommend checking the installation guides and double-checking the connections to secure the car seat in place.
Also, it’s important to regularly check if your car seat’s installation remains secured over time. If possible, check before each use and conduct a daily or weekly check to be sure.
Where Should You Put The Car Seat?
The center or middle back seat may be the safest place to put your child’s car seat. It’s the farthest spot from any window or airbag. Still, any backseat installation can be safe. (11)
LATCH System Vs. Seat Belt
Older vehicles might not have the LATCH system. Don’t worry because car seats are also designed to work with vehicle seat belts.
Can You Use A Lap Belt Instead Of Seat Belt For Installation?
Check your car seat’s installation guide whether lap belts are allowed.
Is It Okay If Your Toddler’s Feet Touches The Vehicle Seat?
Yes. Babies and toddlers are still safer in a rear-facing seat, even if their feet touch the vehicle seat than in a forward-facing installation. (12)
Other Recent Baby Product Recalls & Safety Warnings
Stay informed with the latest news by signing up for our regular Motherhood Community recall alerts so you never miss an important recall.
Check these comprehensive lists of product recalls by category:
- Crib recalls (up to 2022)
- Stroller recalls (2020 to 2023)
- Recalled toys list (2020 to 2023)
- Baby formula recall (2001 to 2022)
- Baby food recall (2015 to 2022)
- Pacifier recall (2019 to 2022)
- Baby wipes recall (2014 to 2022)
REFERENCES
(1) https://www.nhtsa.gov/campaign/right-seat
(2) https://communitychoicepeds.com/the-vital-importance-of-car-seat-safety-protecting-our-most-precious-passengers/
(3) https://www.aap.org/en/patient-care/early-childhood/early-childhood-health-and-development/safe-environments/child-passenger-safety/
(4) https://www.nhtsa.gov/car-seats-and-booster-seats/car-seat-ease-use-ratings
(5) https://www.nhtsa.gov/vehicle-safety/car-seats-and-booster-seats
(6) https://www.childrenscolorado.org/conditions-and-advice/parenting/parenting-articles/car-safety-babies-medical-conditions/
(7) https://www.nhtsa.gov/car-seat/UPPABABY/OTHER/a__4118739#investigations
(8) https://www.nhtsa.gov/car-seats-and-booster-seats/car-seat-use-after-crash
(9) https://www.healthychildren.org/English/safety-prevention/on-the-go/Pages/Car-Safety-Seats-Information-for-Families.aspx
(10) https://elht.nhs.uk/services/maternity-and-newborn-services/keeping-your-baby-safe
(11) https://safeintheseat.com/where-should-you-put-your-car-seat/
(12) https://jeffersoncounty.in.gov/Faq.aspx?QID=81
