Overview
Who wins the Chicco vs. Graco car seat “war”?
Both brands are well-known for making a wide range of high-quality baby products, including car seats, strollers, bassinets, playards, and other things you might need for your baby’s nursery.
In this article, we review some of the main products from both brands to help you find the best car seats for your little one, depending on the type you need:
- Infant car seats (rear-facing only)
- Convertible car seats (converts from rear-facing to forward-facing seats)
- All-in-one car seats (convertible car seat + booster seat)
- Harness booster car seats
- Seat belt-positioning high-back booster seats (including the narrowest booster seats)
- Backless booster seats
- Travel systems (car seats + strollers) – regular stroller type
- Jogger travel systems
Chicco Vs. Graco Car Seat Reviews: Key Points
Here’s a quick summary of these products’ special features and strong points against each other:
Infant Car Seats
Chicco Keyfit 30 Infant Car Seat (ClearText)
- GREENGUARD GOLD Certified for low chemical emissions
- ClearTex fabrics (fire-resistant without using harmful chemical fire retardants)
- Free from toxic chemicals: fire retardant chemical treatments, PFAS (per- and poly-fluoroalkyl substances), BPA (bisphenol-A), and phthalates
- JPMA (Juvenile Products Manufacturers Association) Certified
Graco SnugRide 35 Lite LX Baby Car Seat
- Higher weight and height limits
- Costs less
- Weighs lighter
- No recalls
Convertible Car Seats
Chicco NextFit Max Convertible Car Seat (Zip Air)
- Free from toxic chemicals
- SuperCinch tightener and LockSure belt-tightening system
- 3D AirMesh backrest (breathable fabrics)
- Like other products from the “Zip” line, seat pads are designed for easy removable (for hassle-free clean-ups and washing)
- No recall
Graco Extend2Fit Convertible Car Seat
- Costs less
- More headrest and recline positions
All-In-One Car Seats
Chicco Fit4 Adapt 4-in-1 Convertible Car Seat
- LockSure belt-tightening system (built-in lock-offs)
- Adaptive, humidity-regulating fabric (patented 37.5® Technology and breathable mesh) for controlling the child’s temperature
- Free from toxic chemicals
- Costs less
Graco Premier 4Ever DLX Extend2Fit SnugLock 4-in-1 Car Seat (With Anti-Rebound Bar)
- Higher weight and height limits
- Has anti-rebound bar (an additional layer of safety by limiting seat rotation during impact)
- More modes (also converts into a backless booster)
Harness + Booster Car Seats
Chicco MyFit Zip Air Harness + Booster Car Seat (For Q Collection)
- Breathable backrest for improved ventilation
- More recline and headrest positions
- Free from toxic chemicals
- Contoured ErgoBoost seat using dual-density foam padding
- Easy zip-off design
Graco Nautilus 65 Harness Booster Car Seat (3-in-1)
- Costs less
- More modes (also converts into a backless booster)
Seat Belt-Positioning High-Back Booster Seats
Chicco KidFit Zip Air Plus 2-in-1 Belt-Positioning Booster Car Seat (For Q Collection)
- Unique zip-on cushioned leg rest
- 3D AirMesh with breathable fabrics
- More headrest and recline positions
- Easy zip-off cushions and pads
- Bonus kid console
- Free from toxic chemicals
Graco TurboBooster LX Highback Booster with Latch System
- Costs less
- Hideaway storage compartment and cup holders
Backless Booster Seats
Chicco GoFit Plus Booster Car Seat – Stream
- Free from toxic chemicals
- Built-in carry handle (to make switching between vehicles easier)
- ErgoBoost seat with double-foam padding for added comfort
Graco TurboBooster LX Backless Booster with LATCH
- Costs less
Travel Systems (Car Seats + Strollers) – Regular Stroller Type
Chicco Corso Primo ClearTex Travel System
- JPMA Certified and GREENGUARD Gold Certified
- Free from toxic chemicals
- ClearTex fabrics (fire-resistant without using chemical fire retardants)
- Padded infant insert with organic cotton fabric
- Easy-zip seat pads
- UPF 50+ canopy (Ultraviolet Protection Factor)
Graco Modes Nest2Grow DLX Travel System
- More configuration options
- Also converts to a double stroller
- Costs less
- Silent Shade canopy (quiet adjustments)
Jogger Travel Systems
Chicco Activ3 Jogging Stroller Travel System
- Free from toxic chemicals
- JPMA Certified
- Stroller has a control console (includes a hand-operated parking brake)
- Extendable UPF-rated canopy with reflective details and peek-a-boo windows
- Foot-activated FlexCore adjustable rear suspension
Graco FastAction Fold Jogger Travel System (Click Connect)
- More configuration options
- Higher weight and height limits
- Costs less
- Anti-rebound bar
- Silent Shade canopy (quiet adjustments)
Continue reading for a more detailed comparison of these products:
Infant Car Seats
These rear-facing car seats are meant for newborns and small babies up to around one year old.
Most of these products are compatible with certain strollers (often from the same brand), so they often have handles that work as carriers to move babies without unstrapping them from the car seats.
Chicco Keyfit 30 Infant Car Seat (ClearTex)
What Makes It Special?
- Conversion Options: Rear-facing only
- Recline/Headrest Positions: Five recline positions, three height adjust positions, and one crotch position
- Capacity & Limits: Babies 4-30 lbs or up to 30” tall
Safety Features
- GREENGUARD GOLD Certified for low chemical emissions
- Five-point harness (includes one-pull tightener)
- Carrier shell with EPS (expanded polystyrene) energy-absorbing foam (for impact protection)
- ClearTex fabrics (fire-resistant without using harmful chemical fire retardants)
- Free from fire retardant chemical treatments, PFAS, BPA, and phthalates
Key Features
- Material: 100% polyester fabric, metal, plastic, and EPS foam
- Ease Of Installation: Installs easily with SuperCinch LATCH (uses force-multiplying technology for tightening the connections to reduce car seat movement) or the vehicle seat belt
- Washable Parts: Machine-washable seat pad (cold water on delicate cycle); drip-dry only
- Stroller Compatibility: All full-sized strollers, joggers, frame strollers, and double Chicco strollers (no need for adapters); some lightweight Chicco strollers (e.g., Mini Bravo Plus and Presto)
- Dimensions: 27.5” x 16.5” x 24”
- Weight: 9.5 lbs (car seat only); 7 lbs (base)
Other Specifications
- Certification: JPMA (Juvenile Products Manufacturers Association) Certified and GREENGUARD Gold Certified
- Warranty: Not indicated; consumers are directed to message the company for warranty questions (chiccousa.com/contactus)
- Expiration: Check the label on the car seat’s base for the expiration date
- FAA Approval: Yes
Extra Features
- Removable head and body support (fits newborns weighing 4-11 lbs)
- Bubble level indicators and a spring-loaded leveling foot to get the right base angle
Product Recall
- No new recalls
- In August 2018, close to 45,100 car seats were recalled in Canada for not meeting the Canadian Motor vehicle safety standard, posing safety concerns; this recall didn’t include products sold in the US (1)
- In June 2008, Chicco USA recalled 18,000 bases used for KeyFit and KeyFit 30 car seats and Cortina Travel Systems due to a manufacturing defect that can make the seat slip from the base, posing injury risks (2)
Cons
- Lower capacity, heavier, and pricier than Graco SnugRide 35 Lite LX
- Only compatible with Chicco strollers
- Some complaints about difficulties in releasing the seat from the base and the product being heavier than the advertised weight
Customer Reviews
“This is the easiest car seat to operate after having 3 different ones for 5 different children.” – Reviewer on Chicco USA
“One huge lie that made me buy this product. In the description it says item weight 9 lb. In reality it is 17 lb.” – Reviewer on Amazon
Graco SnugRide 35 Lite LX Baby Car Seat
What Makes It Special?
- Conversion Options: Rear-facing only
- Recline/Headrest Positions: Four positions (adjustable base); includes level indicators and a spring-loaded leveling foot to get the right base angle
- Capacity & Limits: Babies 4-35 lbs or up to 32” tall; baby’s head should be at least 1” below the car seat’s top
Safety Features
- Graco ProtectPlus Engineered (helps protect in side, frontal, rear, and rollover crashes)
- Passes frontal crash tests under US FMVSS 213 (Federal Motor Vehicle Safety Standards)
- Soft-knit infant head and body supports
- Five-point harness
Key Features
- Material: Metal, plastic, foam, and fabric
- Ease Of Installation: LATCH-equipped car base for easy installation
- Washable Parts: Machine-washable seat pads and canopy; drip-dry only
- Stroller Compatibility: One-step secure connection to Graco strollers and infant car seat bases
- Dimensions: 15.5 x 27.4 x 18.07 inches
- Weight: 7.5 lbs (without base); 12.3 lbs (set)
Other Specifications
- Certification: FMVSS 213
- Warranty: One year
- Expiration: Seven years after the manufacturing date (check your car seat’s label)
- FAA Approval: Check the label on your car seat for the FAA approval
Extra Features
- Removable two-piece support for head and body (to keep a baby as small as 4 lbs snug in the seat)
- One hand, click-in attachment for compatible strollers
- Removable, multi-position canopy
Product Recall
- None
Cons
- Unlike the Chicco Keyfit 30, it doesn’t have GREENGUARD GOLD certification
- Some complaints about the lack of sufficient padding for newborns and small babies
Customer Reviews
“This seat is lightweight and very easy to use!” – Reviewer on Graco Baby
“The padding is not sufficient for supporting a newborn baby head. Very disappointing because I don’t feel confident in its safety or comfort.” – Reviewer on Graco Baby
Convertible Car Seats
Because baby car seats don’t convert to a forward-facing car seat, many parents prefer convertible car seats, so they won’t need to buy a new one after a few months.
Although they also work as infant car seats, convertibles are designed to stay latched to the car seat. They can’t be attached to strollers.
Chicco NextFit Max Convertible Car Seat (Zip Air)
What Makes It Special?
- Conversion Options: Rear-facing and forward-facing modes; includes 25% more legroom than other Chicco NextFit Zip car seats
- Recline/Headrest Positions: Nine-position headrest system and two crotch positions; one-hand adjustment
- Capacity & Limits: 50 lbs (rear-facing mode) or up to 43” tall; 65 lbs (forward-facing mode) or up to 49” tall
Safety Features
- DuoGuard (a deep rigid shell + EPS energy-absorbing foam)
- SuperCinch tightener and LockSure belt-tightening system
- LockSure steel frame-reinforced seat shell for superior impact protection
- Free from PFAS, BPA, phthalates, and chlorinated or brominated fire retardant chemical treatments
- Five-point harness
Key Features
- Material: Steel, plastic, foam, and 100% polyester fabric
- Ease Of Installation: Easy to install using LATCH connectors or the vehicle seat belt
- Washable Parts: Zip-off, machine-washable seat pads
- Stroller Compatibility: None
- Dimensions: 22.75” x 19” x 26”
- Weight: 26.5 lbs
Other Specifications
- Certification: Not indicated
- Warranty: Not indicated; consumers are instructed to message the company for warranty questions (chiccousa.com/contactus)
- Expiration: Check the label on the car seat’s base for the expiration date
- FAA Approval: Yes
Extra Features
- 3D AirMesh backrest (breathable fabric for enhanced ventilation and airflow)
- Removable newborn positioner or infant inserts (to support babies 4-11 lbs)
- Bubble leveling system
- Dishwasher-safe, easy-to-clean cup holder (space-saving)
- Zip products are designed for easy seat pad removable for hassle-free clean-ups and washing
Product Recall
- None
Cons
- Pricier than Graco Extend2Fit
- Some complaints about the car seat being too bulky or difficult to install
Customer Reviews
“Really nice. Easily cleanable and comfortable for the kids.” – Reviewer on Chicco USA
“Super bulky car seat, leaves little to no room for a front passenger in smaller vehicles or in my case a truck with an extended cab.” – Reviewer on Chicco USA
Graco Extend2Fit Convertible Car Seat
What Makes It Special?
- Conversion Options: Rear-facing and forward-facing modes
- Recline/Headrest Positions: 10 headrest height positions; six recline positions
- Capacity & Limits: 4-50 lbs (rear-facing mode) or must be at least 1” below the handle; 22-65 lbs (forward-facing mode) or up to 49” tall
Safety Features
- Graco ProtectPlus Engineered (frontal, rear, rollover, or side impact protection)
- No-Rethread Simply Safe Adjust Harness System (allows height adjustments for harness and headrest in one motion)
- InRight LATCH harness for a one-second LATCH attachment (features an audible click to help you determine if the car seat has been installed securely)
- Meets or exceeds the frontal crash test under the child restraint criteria of the US FMVSS 213
- Meets Graco’s RollSafe testing standards (using European rollover testing procedures)
- Built-in 5-point harness system that passes the side-impact occupant retention test
- Passes the European Rear-Impact Crash Pulse
- Steel-reinforced frame (the brand claims this can help provide durability and strength for up to 10 years)
- Five-point harness
Key Features
- Material: Metal, plastic, foam, and fabric
- Ease Of Installation: LATCH connectors, second LATCH attachment, or the vehicle’s seat belts
- Washable Parts: Machine-washable seat pads
- Stroller Compatibility: None
- Dimensions: 23.5” x 19.5” x 21.5”
- Weight: 19 lbs
Other Specifications
- Certification: FMVSS 213
- Warranty: One year
- Expiration: 10 years after the manufacturing date (check your car seat’s label)
- FAA Approval: Check the label on your car seat for the FAA approval
Extra Features
- Extend2Fit four-position extension panel (provides up to 5” extra legroom to let your child ride longer in rear-facing mode)
- Harness storage pockets (handy when you’re trying to put the baby in or out of the car seat)
- Removable infant inserts for head and body
- Two easy-to-clean cup holders
Product Recall
- Over 15,000 units of this car seat were recalled in 2016 because of an error in the recline label, making it fail regulatory guidelines; this recall is no longer in effect (3)
Cons
- The 2016 model of this car seat had a recall.
Customer Reviews
“I love the foot extender! It makes it so easy for my son to be rear facing for as long as he needs to be and be comfortable.” – Reviewer on Graco Baby
“I absolutely hate this car seat. I don’t feel like the shoulder straps are long enough.” – Reviewer on Graco Baby
All-In-One Car Seats
These car seats can be used in rear-facing (infant) and front-facing modes, plus as booster seats.
Chicco Fit4 Adapt 4-in-1 Convertible Car Seat
What Makes It Special?
- Conversion Options: Rear-facing (with and without infant inserts) and front-facing modes plus high-back booster seat
- Recline/Headrest Positions: 10 headrest positions, nine leveling positions, and two crotch positions
- Capacity & Limits: 4-16 lbs (rear-facing, with infant inserts), 12-40 lbs (rear-facing) or up to 43” tall, 25-65 lbs (front-facing) or up to 54” tall, and 40-100 lbs (booster) or 38-57” tall
Safety Features
- DuoGuard for two layers of protection (steel-reinforced rigid shell + EPS energy-absorbing foam)
- Adaptive, humidity-regulating fabric (with breathable mesh and patented 37.5® Technology) for controlling the child’s temperature
- Fabrics are embedded with naturally derived volcanic mineral particles to help regulate heat (returns infrared energy to help warm the child’s body or speeds evaporation to help them cool down)
- LockSure belt-tightening system (built-in lock-offs and an easy-thread belt path)
- Free from fire retardant chemical treatments (brominated or chlorinated), phthalates, PFAS, and BPAs
Key Features
- Material: Steel, plastic, foam, regular polyester, and patented 37.5® polyester
- Ease Of Installation: LATCH connectors and SuperCinch tightener
- Washable Parts: Machine-washable seat pads
- Stroller Compatibility: None
- Dimensions: 22” x 19” x 27”
- Weight: 26 lbs
Other Specifications
- Certification: Not indicated
- Warranty: Not indicated; consumers are directed to message the company for warranty questions (chiccousa.com/contactus)
- Expiration: Check the label on the car seat’s base for the expiration date
- FAA Approval: Not indicated
Extra Features
- Slim design
- Removable, space-saving cup holders
- Fit4Stages.com transition guide (with easy-access QR codes)
Product Recall
- None
Cons
- Some complaints about the product’s design, straps that are difficult to loosen, or threads that can be painful on the skin
- Unlike the Graco Premier 4Ever DLX Extend2Fit SnugLock, it doesn’t have an anti-rebound bar; its “4-in-1” options might be considered by parents as “3-in-1” (because the two rear-facing infant car seat modes are only counted as one)
Customer Reviews
“It seems super comfy for my baby, and also super secure.” – Reviewer on Chicco USA
“The adaptative fabric has a bad finish all around it, where the threads stick the child. My daughter cries all the time and can’t sleep using it.” – Reviewer on Chicco USA
Graco Premier 4Ever DLX Extend2Fit SnugLock 4-in-1 Car Seat (With Anti-Rebound Bar)
What Makes It Special?
- Conversion Options: Rear-facing and front-facing modes plus high-back belt-positioning and backless boosters
- Recline/Headrest Positions: 10 headrest positions and six recline positions
- Capacity & Limits: 4-50 lbs (rear-facing), 22-65 lbs (forward-facing), 40-100 lbs (high-back belt-positioning booster), and 40-120 lbs (backless booster)
Safety Features
- Anti-rebound bar
- Graco ProtectPlus Engineered (passes the most rigorous crash tests to help protect your little one in frontal, rear, rollover, or side crashes)
- Extend2Fit adjustable extension panel (four positions) for additional legroom of up to 5” (lets children ride longer using the rear-facing mode
- No-Rethread Simply Safe Adjust Harness System (lets you adjust the harness and headrest positions in one motion)
- InRight LATCH harness (one-second LATCH attachment with an audible click to help you determine if the seat has been properly secured)
- Steel-reinforced frame (the brand claims that this helps keep the car seat’s strength and durability for up to 10 years of use
- EPS energy-absorbing foam (helps protect during impact)
- Passes Graco’s RollSafe European-based rollover testing standards
- 5-point harness system
- Side-impact tested (occupant retention)
- Rear-impact tested (European Rear-Impact Crash Pulse)
- Meets about twice the impact force required under the car seat safety standards of US FMVSS 213
Key Features
- Material: Steel, plastic, EPS foam, and fabric
- Ease Of Installation: SnugLock Technology for easy installation
- Washable Parts: Rapid-remove, machine-washable cover (removes in 60 seconds without removing the harness straps or uninstalling the seat)
- Stroller Compatibility: None
- Dimensions: 23.5” x 19” x 28.5”
- Weight: 28.1 lbs
Other Specifications
- Certification: Meets or exceeds the frontal crash test of the US FMVSS 213 under the child restraint criteria
- Warranty: One year
- Expiration: 10 years from manufacturing date (check the product’s label)
- FAA Approval: Check the label on your car seat for the FAA approval
Extra Features
- Rubberized, no-slip grip harness storage pockets (keep the harness out of the way so you can get your baby in and out easily; it also keeps the harness when the product is used as a booster seat)
- Removable infant inserts (for head and body)
- Easy-to-clean cup holders
Product Recall
- None
Cons
- Pricier than the Chicco Fit4 Adapt 4-in-1
Customer Reviews
“It was easy to install this car seat and it only took a few minutes to clip it in.” – Reviewer on Graco Baby
“The sides of the plastic from the strap buckles dig into my daughters little legs and have left her bruised and crying.” – Reviewer on Graco Baby
Harness + Booster Car Seats
These products are designed for older kids. They can’t be used as rear-facing baby car seats.
Chicco MyFit Zip Air Harness + Booster Car Seat (For Q Collection)
What Makes It Special?
- Conversion Options: Front-facing harness mode and belt-positioning booster mode
- Recline/Headrest Positions: Four recline positions, nine headrest positions, and two crotch positions
- Capacity & Limits: 25-65 lbs, at least two years old, and up to 54” tall for harness mode; 40-100 lbs, at least four years old, and 38-57” tall for booster mode
Safety Features
- DuoGuard with two layers of protection: a rigid shell (reinforced with a steel frame) and EPS energy-absorbing foam
- Five-point padded, no-rethread harness that converts to belt-positioning booster
- Breathable backrest for improved ventilation
- ReclineSure leveling system
- RideRight bubble levels (to verify installation angle)
- SuperCinch tightener
- LockSure belt-tightening system
- Free from chlorinated brominated fire retardant chemicals, BPA PFAS, or phthalates
Key Features
- Material: Steel, plastic, foam, and 100% polyester fabric
- Ease Of Installation: Premium LATCH connectors or the vehicle seat belt
- Washable Parts: Machine-washable, easy-to-remove seat pads
- Stroller Compatibility: None
- Dimensions: 21” x 17.5” x 26”
- Weight: 26 lbs
Other Specifications
- Warranty: Not indicated; consumers are directed to message the company for warranty questions (chiccousa.com/contactus)
- Expiration: Check the label on the car seat’s base for the expiration date
- FAA Approval: Yes, harness mode only; booster mode isn’t certified for aircraft use
Extra Features
- Contoured ErgoBoost seat using dual-density foam padding
- Padded waist belt
- Dishwasher-safe cup holders (can fold out of the way for space-saving)
- Bonus storage console
- Easy zip-off design for faster seat cover removal and replacement
Product Recall
- None
Cons
- Some complaints about the product being smaller than advertised or having painful straps
- Pricier than Graco Nautilus 65
- Only two configurations (Graco Nautilus 65 has three)
Customer Reviews
“This is our first Chicco seat and the install was super quick and there was no doubt it was anchored in tight enough.” – Reviewer on Chicco USA
“This poorly crafted product is advertised for “big” kids, but it’s smaller than shown.” – Reviewer on Amazon
Graco Nautilus 65 Harness Booster Car Seat (3-in-1)
What Makes It Special?
- Conversion Options: 5-point harnessed front-facing car seat mode, high-back belt-positioning booster seat, and backless booster
- Recline/Headrest Positions: Three recline positions
- Capacity & Limits: 22-65 lbs for the harnessed car seat, 30-100 lbs for the high-back belt-positioning booster, and 40-100 lbs for the backless belt-positioning booster
Safety Features
- No-rethread Simply Safe Adjust Harness System (helps adjust the headrest height and harness in one motion)
- Side-impact tested under the NCAP (New Car Assessment Program) peak crash force test
- EPS energy-absorbing foam
- Designed and tested to meet US standard FMVSS 213
- Meets rigorous US safety standards and crash tests
- Built-in 5-point harness system meets side-impact tests for occupant retention
Key Features
- Material: Metal, plastic, foam, and fabric
- Ease Of Installation: Open-loop belt guides
- Washable Parts: Machine-washable seat pad, buckle, and harness covers
- Stroller Compatibility: None
- Dimensions: 28” x 18”
- Weight: 20.52 lbs
Other Specifications
- Certification: US standard FMVSS 213
- Warranty: One year
- Expiration: 10 years from the manufacturing date (check the label)
- FAA Approval: Not indicated
Extra Features
- Contoured armrests
- Storage pockets
- Cup holder
Product Recall
- In February 2014, 3.7 million Graco car seats (manufactured from 2009 to July 2013), including the Nautilus 3-in-1, were recalled due to buckle issues (the red release button can become stuck or difficult to unlatch); the recall is no longer in effect (4)
Cons
- It had a recall in 2014 over buckle issues.
Customer Reviews
“Love how easy it is to loosen straps for getting her out comfortably, and to tighten the straps to restrain her safely.” – Reviewer on Walmart
“This car seat did not securely attach to either of the three vehicles we tested it in. It is extremely unsafe and we promptly returned it.” – Reviewer on Graco Baby
Seat Belt-Positioning High-Back Booster Seats
These products are for older kids (no 5-point harness for younger kids).
Chicco KidFit Zip Air Plus 2-in-1 Belt-Positioning Booster Car Seat (For Q Collection)
What Makes It Special?
- Conversion Options: Belt-positioning high-back booster car seat and backless booster seat
- Recline/Headrest Positions: 10 headrest and torso positions; two recline positions
- Capacity & Limits: 40-100 lbs, at least fours years old, and 38-57” tall for high-back mode; 40-110 lbs in backless mode, but the child can sit in the same seated position during the car ride
Safety Features
- 3D AirMesh with breathable fabrics for better air circulation
- DuoGuard for two layers of protection: a rigid shell (with steel reinforcement) and high-quality EPS energy-absorbing foam
- Force-multiplying SuperCinch one-pull tightener (stabilizes the seat)
- Free from chlorinated or brominated fire retardants, phthalates, PFAS, and BPAs
Key Features
- Material: Metal, foam, plastic, and 100% polyester fabric
- Ease Of Installation: Premium, quick-release LATCH connections for one-hand removal
- Washable Parts: Removable and machine washable fabrics, including the seat pads and armrest covers
- Stroller Compatibility: None
- Dimensions: 20” x 17” x 26”
- Weight: 11 lbs
Other Specifications
- Certification: Not indicated
- Warranty: Not indicated; consumers are directed to message the company for warranty questions (chiccousa.com/contactus)
- Expiration: Check the label on the car seat’s base for the expiration date
- FAA Approval: Not indicated
Extra Features
- Integrated side wings
- Easy zip-off cushions and pads
- Contoured ErgoBoost Plus seat with extra padding (three layers of foam) for added comfort
- Unique zip-on cushioned leg rest
- Removable 2-position backrest (mimics the vehicle seat position)
- Extra padding
- Two space-saving cup holders
- Bonus kid console
Product Recall
- None
Cons
- Pricier than the Graco TurboBooster LX
- Had a lawsuit over “misrepresented” claims (see below)
On March 8, 2023, a United States District Court (Southern District of New York) announced the settlement of a case against Artsana USA, Inc. (Chicco’s parent company) over the Chicco-branded “KidFit” booster seats. (5)
Affected booster car seat models: (5)
- KidFit
- KidFit Zip
- KidFit Zip Air
- KidFit Luxe
- KidFit Plus
- KidFit Air Plus
The lawsuit alleged that the company misrepresented the product’s minimum weight limit and side-impact collision protection. (5)
The announcement clarified that the settlement wasn’t an admission of wrongdoing but was done to avoid the expense of continuing the lawsuit. (5)
Customers who bought Chicco “KidFit” branded booster seats from April 22, 2015, through December 31, 2021, are eligible for: (5)
- $50 (with proof of purchase or they bought the product directly from chiccousa.com)
- $25 (without proof of purchase)
Affected customers can also get more information from ArtsanaBoosterSeatSettlement.com. (5)
Customer Reviews
“This is the only booster seat we have found that my son doesn’t complain about his legs feeling tingly.” – Reviewer on Chicco USA
“The latch that holds the back onto the base keeps slipping when I try to tilt it backward.” – Reviewer on Chicco USA
Graco TurboBooster LX Highback Booster with Latch System
What Makes It Special?
- Conversion Options: High-back and backless booster modes
- Recline/Headrest Positions: Six-position headrest
- Capacity & Limits: 40-100 lbs, 4-10 years old, or up to 57” tall
Safety Features
- Full coverage back support
- Open-loop belt guides
- Graco ProtectPlus Engineered (designed and tested to help protect children in rear, frontal, and rollover crashes
- EPS energy-absorbing foam
Key Features
- Material: Metal, plastic, foam, and fabric
- Ease Of Installation: LATCH system with one-hand front adjustment
- Washable Parts: Machine-washable seat cushion
- Stroller Compatibility: None
- Dimensions: 25.4” x 10.5”
- Weight: 10.76 lbs
Other Specifications
- Certification: Not indicated
- Warranty: One year
- Expiration: 10 years after the manufacturing date (check your product’s label)
- FAA Approval: Not approved
Extra Features
- Hideaway cup holders
- Hideaway storage compartment
- Height-adjustable head support
Product Recall
- None
Cons
- Unlike the Chicco KidFit Zip Air Plus, it doesn’t have cushioned leg rest.
Customer Reviews
“Very easy to assemble and install. My son loves that he can buckle/unbuckle himself now.” – Reviewer on Graco Baby
“This car seat would be absolutely perfect if it had anchors! How unsafe that without anchors the car seat can just fly around.” Reviewer on Graco Baby
Backless Booster Seats
Chicco GoFit Plus Booster Car Seat
What Makes It Special?
- Conversion Options: Backless booster seat only
- Recline/Headrest Positions: Not applicable
- Capacity & Limits: 40-110 lbs, at least four years old, and 38-57” tall; the child must be able to sit in the same seated position during the car ride
Safety Features
- Integrated lap belt guides
- Shoulder belt clip
- Free from PFAS, BPA, phthalates, and brominated or chlorinated fire retardants
Key Features
- Material: Metal, plastic, foam, and 100% polyester fabric
- Ease Of Installation: One-hand, quick-release LATCH attachment
- Washable Parts: Removable, machine-washable fabrics, including the armrest covers
- Stroller Compatibility: None
- Dimensions: 15” x 17” x 8.5”
- Weight: 6 lbs
Other Specifications
- Certification: Not indicated
- Warranty: Not indicated; consumers are directed to message the company for warranty questions (chiccousa.com/contactus)
- Expiration: Check the label on the car seat’s base for the expiration date
- FAA Approval: Not approved
Extra Features
- Built-in carry handle (to make switching between vehicles easier)
- ErgoBoost seat with double-foam padding for added comfort
- Two removable, dishwasher-safe cup holders
- Smooth, non-marking underside (can help protect the vehicle seats from damage)
Product Recall
- None
Cons
- Pricier than Graco TurboBooster LX Backless Booster
- Some complaints about difficulties in installing the booster seat
Customer Reviews
“Easy to install and release. Store’s conveniently.” – Reviewer on Chicco USA
“Bad Latch system. Won’t click into latch.” – Reviewer on Chicco USA
Graco TurboBooster LX Backless Booster with LATCH
What Makes It Special?
- Conversion Options: Backless booster seat only
- Recline/Headrest Positions: Not applicable
- Capacity & Limits: 40-100 lbs and 43-57” tall
Safety Features
- Secure connection to keep the booster seat steady whether occupied or not
- Graco ProtectPlus Engineered: designed and tested for the most rigorous crash tests to help protect children during a rear, frontal, and rollover crash
- Shoulder belt positioner to help properly install and position the vehicle’s seat belt
Key Features
- Material: Metal, foam, plastic, and fabric
- Ease Of Installation: Front-adjust LATCH system for quick installation
- Washable Parts: Removable, machine-washable seat pad
- Stroller Compatibility: None
- Dimensions: 17.5” x 8.64” x 15.5”
- Weight: 5.56 lbs (according to Amazon)
Other Specifications
- Certification: Not indicated
- Warranty: One year
- Expiration: 10 years after the manufacturing date
- FAA Approval: Not approved
Extra Features
- Easy-to-clean cup holder
Product Recall
- None
Cons
- Some complaints about potential safety issues (child tipping over)
Customer Reviews
“I like the fact that it latches to the back seat hooks. Makes it a lot safer.” – Reviewer on Graco Baby
“There’s literally nothing keeping your child from tipping over, even when you turn the corner.” – Reviewer on Graco Baby
Travel Systems (Car Seats + Strollers) – Regular Stroller Type
Chicco Corso Primo ClearTex Travel System
This travel system features the following:
Corso Primo ClearTex Modular Stroller
KeyFit 35 Zip ClearTex Infant Car Seat
What Makes It Special?
- Conversion Options: Infant car seat, carriage (with the car seat attached to the stroller), and toddler stroller
- Recline/Headrest Positions: Six configurations
- Capacity & Limits: 4-35 lbs and up to 32” tall (infant car seat); up to 50 lbs (stroller)
Safety Features
- Both the stroller and the car seat are GREENGUARD Gold Certified (low chemical emissions)
- Free from fire retardant chemicals, BPA, PFAS, and phthalates
- ClearTex fabrics (fire-resistant fabrics without using chemical fire retardants)
- Easy-extend headrest system for the infant car seat
- Integrated anti-rebound bar (limits car seat rotation in a crash)
- No-rethread harness
- SuperCinch force-multiplying tightener
- RideRight bubble levels and ReclineSure leveling foot (helps ensure proper seat installation in the car)
- UPF 50+ canopy
- Secure click-in attachment (compatible with all Chicco infant car seats); uses car seat adapter (included)
- LockSure steel-reinforced seat belt locking system
Key Features
- Material: Metal, plastic, foam, fabrics (polyester seat pads, 100% organic cotton inserts), and premium leatherette; PVC (polyvinyl chloride) for the parent handle
- Ease Of Installation: Premium LATCH connectors; integrated European belt routing (used for carrier-only installation)
- Washable Parts: Machine-washable quick-remove seat pad
- Stroller Compatibility: All full-sized strollers, joggers, frame strollers, and double Chicco strollers (no need for adapters); some lightweight Chicco strollers (e.g., Mini Bravo Plus and Presto)
- Dimensions: 28” x 15.5” x 22.5” (for the car seat); 34.5” x 24.8” x 42.8” (assembled, unfolded stroller)
- Weight: 10 lbs (infant car seat); 24.8 lbs (stroller frame + toddler seat)
Other Specifications
- Certification: JPMA Certified and GREENGUARD Gold Certified
- Warranty: Not indicated; consumers are directed to message the company for warranty questions (chiccousa.com/contactus)
- Expiration: Check the label on the car seat’s base for the expiration date
- FAA Approval: Yes (infant car seat)
Extra Features
For the car seat:
- Padded infant insert with organic cotton fabric
- Easy-zip seat pads
For the stroller:
- One-hand, quick-fold design
- Removable multi-reclining toddler seat
- Front suspension and adjustable FlexCore rear suspension
- Large wheels (foam-filled rubber tires)
- Wheel and swivel bearings
- Adjustable footrest
- Zip-extend canopy with mesh panel
- Zip-open full-coverage privacy shield
- Extra-large storage basket (under the seat)
- Zippered pocket (back of toddler seat)
- Large mesh pouch (back of toddler seat)
- Two expandable bottle pockets
- Organizer pockets
Product Recall
- None
Cons
- Pricier than Graco Modes Nest2Grow DLX
- Some complaints about product quality and design
Customer Reviews
“This is the perfect pair! Very easy to install in the car, easy to transition from stroller to car seat and overall very lightweight!” – Reviewer on Chicco USA
“Infant seat wiggles on the frame while in the stroller. Stroller basket is too narrow.” – Reviewer on Amazon
Graco Modes Nest2Grow DLX Travel System
This travel system features the following:
Graco Nest2Grow Stroller
Graco SnugRide SnugLock 35 DLX Infant Car Seat
What Makes It Special?
- Conversion Options: Infant car seat, infant carriage (stroller + installed car seat), single toddler stroller, and double stroller (with a second seat or carry cot, both sold separately)
- Recline/Headrest Positions: 15 stroller configurations, three height positions (stroller), and five recline positions (infant car seat)
- Capacity & Limits: 4-35 lbs and up to 32” tall (infant car seat), but the baby’s head must be at least 1” below the car seat’s top; up to 50 lbs (stroller)
Safety Features
- Convertible 3- or 5-point harness (stroller only); the infant car seat has a 5-point harness
- Anti-rebound bar
- No-rethread Simply Safe Adjust harness system (car seat)
- Graco ProtectPlus Engineered (helps protect in rollover, frontal, rear, and side crashes)
Key Features
- Material: Metal, plastic, foam, and fabric
- Ease Of Installation: InRight LATCH attachment (easy, one-second attachment to vehicle)
- Washable Parts: Machine-washable seat pads and canopy
- Stroller Compatibility: One-step secure connection to Graco strollers and infant car seat bases
- Dimensions: 17.5” x 25.5” x 27.5” (infant car seat); 43” x 26.4” x 44.5” (stroller)
- Weight: 17.24 lbs (car seat); 30.6 lbs (stroller)
Other Specifications
- Certification: Not indicated
- Warranty: One year
- Expiration: Seven years from the manufacturing date (check your car seat’s label)
- FAA Approval: Check the label on your car seat for the FAA approval
Extra Features
For the car seat:
- Silent Shade canopy (can be adjusted quietly to avoid disturbing a sleeping baby)
- Rapid-remove seat pads
- Padded harness covers
- Infant insert
- Bubble level indicator
For the stroller:
- Reversible stroller seat (front or rear modes)
- Multi-position reclining seat
- One-step, self-standing folding stroller
- Slide2Me height-adjustable seat (three positions available for the car seat attachment)
- Expandable canopy (two positions)
- Removable child’s tray (includes cup holder)
- Removable parent cup holder
Product Recall
- None
Cons
- Unlike Chicco Corso Primo ClearTex, it isn’t GREENGUARD GOLD Certified
- Some complaints about design issues (requires adapters) and faulty tires
Customer Reviews
“Best feature is the slide to raise the seat. No bending over to get baby in and out! Having the bassinet option is handy too.” – Reviewer on Graco Baby
“What bugged me the most is how they have adapters to snap in a car seat. Why couldn’t they have them built in already?” – Reviewer on Graco Baby
Jogger Travel Systems
Chicco Activ3 Jogging Stroller Travel System
This travel system features the following:
Chicco Activ3 Stroller
Chicco KeyFit 30 Infant Car Seat
What Makes It Special?
- Conversion Options: Infant car seat, stroller + car seat, and jogger stroller modes
- Recline/Headrest Positions: Four-position padded handle (stroller)
- Capacity & Limits: 4-30 lbs and up to 30” tall (infant car seat); up to 50 lbs (stroller)
Safety Features
- Secure, click-in attachment (doesn’t require adapters to attach the car seat to the stroller)
- Stroller has a control console (includes a hand-operated parking brake)
- Extendable UPF-rated canopy (includes reflective details and peek-a-boo windows)
- ReclineSure leveling foot and two RideRight bubble level indicators to ensure proper car seat installation
- 5-point harness with one-pull SuperCinch force-multiplying tightener
- EPS energy-absorbing foam
- Free from fire retardant chemicals, BPA, PFAS, and phthalates
Key Features
- Material: Metal, plastic, foam, and 100% polyester fabrics; PVC (footrest and canopy window)
- Ease Of Installation: Premium LATCH connectors
- Washable Parts: Machine-washable seat pads (car seat); hand-washable fabrics (stroller)
- Stroller Compatibility: All full-sized strollers, joggers, frame strollers, and double Chicco strollers (no need for adapters); some lightweight Chicco strollers (e.g., Mini Bravo Plus and Presto)
- Dimensions: 22” x 17” x 24” (for the car seat); 47.5” x 25” x 42” (assembled stroller)
- Weight: 9.6 lbs (car seat without base); 27.5 lbs (stroller)
Other Specifications
- Certification: JPMA Certified
- Warranty: Not indicated; consumers are directed to message the company for warranty questions (chiccousa.com/contactus)
- Expiration: Check the label on the car seat’s base for the expiration date
- FAA Approval: Yes (infant car seat)
Extra Features
For the car seat:
- Padded infant car seats
For the stroller:
- Lightweight aluminum frame and sleek three-wheel design
- Foot-activated FlexCore adjustable rear suspension
- Foam-filled tires
- Parent tray with large storage and two cup holders
- One-hand, quick-fold design
- Footrest
Product Recall
- None
Cons
- Pricier than Graco FastAction Fold Jogger Click Connect
- Some complaints about the canopy and the travel system being bulky
Customer Reviews
“The stroller is all terrain, easy to maneuver, and folds up hassle-free for transporting.” – Reviewer on Amazon
“The biggest thing i would want to change is the canopy on the carseat. The material get stuck a lot when i try to put the bar back and its very frustrating.” – Reviewer on Chicco USA
Graco FastAction Fold Jogger Travel System (Click Connect)
This travel system features the following:
Graco FastAction Fold Jogger Click Connect Stroller
Graco SnugRide 35 LX Infant Car Seat (Click Connect)
What Makes It Special?
- Conversion Options: Infant car seat, car seat + stroller, and jogger stroller modes
- Recline/Headrest Positions: Five recline positions (car seat) and four recline positions (stroller)
- Capacity & Limits: 4-35 lbs and up to 32” tall (infant car seat)
Safety Features
- Connect technology (one-step, secure connection of the infant car seat to the stroller)
- Convertible 3- or 5-point harness (stroller)
- No-rethread Simply Safe Adjust harness system (car seat)
- Anti-rebound bar
- Two-step brakes
Key Features
- Material: Metal, plastic, foam, and fabric
- Ease Of Installation: InRight LATCH (one-second LATCH attachment)
- Washable Parts: Removable, machine-washable seat cushion (car seat)
- Stroller Compatibility: One-step secure connection to Graco strollers and infant car seat bases
- Dimensions: 30.7” x 15.6” x 11.75” (car seat) ; 40” x 24” x 42” (stroller)
- Weight: 31.99 lbs (stroller)
Other Specifications
- Certification: Not indicated
- Warranty: One year
- Expiration: Seven years from the manufacturing date (check the label for your product’s expiry)
- FAA Approval: Check the label on your car seat for the FAA approval
Extra Features
For the car seat:
- Silent Shade canopy (quiet adjustments)
- Padded harness covers
For the stroller:
- Multi-position reclining seat
- One-second, one-hand FastAction fold
- Lockable front wheels (lock for added stability during runs; unlock for maneuverability on daily strolls)
- Removable child’s tray
- Parent’s tray with a storage compartment, two cup holders, and a smartphone holder
- Extra-large storage basket
Product Recall
- None
Cons
- Some complaints about this product’s wheels
Customer Reviews
“Car seat base is easy to install and car seat is super easy to attach/detach from base.” – Reviewer on Amazon
“It is extremely hard to push because it CONSTANTLY pulls to the right.” – Reviewer on Graco Baby
Summary & Conclusions: Which Is Better, Chicco Or Graco?
Which Car Seat Brand Is Better?
Each brand has a wide range of strollers with different features that make them a better choice, depending on what parents are looking for in the baby products they want to buy.
In general, here are their best points:
- Chicco’s car seats usually have more features (extra bells and whistles) and are free from toxic chemicals; some even have JPMA and GREENGUARD GOLD Certification
- Graco’s car seats usually cost less
Which Brand Is Safer?
- Chicco
Which Brand Is Cheaper?
- Graco
Which Brand Has More Comfortable Car Seats?
This depends on the particular product, but Chicco might also win this round for having breathable fabrics, more recline and headrest positions (in several comparisons we made), and extra features (e.g., unique zip-on cushioned leg rest in the Chicco KidFit Zip Air Plus 2-in-1).
Our Car Seat Recommendations (Alternatives To Chicco & Graco)
- Nuna Exec All-in-One Convertible Car Seat
- UPPAbaby Mesa Max Infant Car Seat
- Britax Boulevard Clicktight Convertible Car Seat
- Clek Foonf Convertible Car Seat
- Doona Infant Car Seat & Stroller
FAQs
What Is The Number 1 Safest Infant Car Seat?
Many brands claim to be the number one. We choose Nuna car seats because they’re GREENGUARD Gold-certified and use naturally flame-resistant materials free from harmful fire retardant chemicals.
Is Chicco Compatible With Graco?
- No
Guide To Buying Car Seats
Safety
Protect your children from the ill effects of toxic chemicals (e.g., BPAs, heavy metals, fire retardants, and phthalates) by only choosing safe products.
Read and bookmark Motherhood Community’s health and safety philosophy to learn more about these harmful chemicals, their potential dangers, and how you can reduce your children’s exposure.
Car Seat Expiration Dates
Car seats are expected to protect children, but their parts and materials can weaken with use and over time, eventually making these baby products possibly unsafe.
A weakened or damaged car seat might no longer be strong enough to protect your child in a crash.
Expiry dates can vary. Check your car seat’s label.
Age Recommendations & Limits
Always follow the manufacturer’s weight and height limits.
Car Seat Types & Your Baby’s Age
Always choose the correct car seat type depending on your child’s age and height or weight to ensure optimal protection.
Easy Installation
This is important to ensure you don’t have to struggle in installing the car seats or taking them out.
Avoid Buying Or Using Secondhand Car Seats
They might be cheaper, but these products might already be unsafe due to wear and tear, old (possibly beyond the expiration date), or have been involved in a crash.
Car seats involved in accidents can be unsafe.
Monitor Car Seat Recalls
- Cybex recall (2023)
- Maxi Cosi recalls (2023)
- Safety 1st recalls (2023)
- Baby Trend stroller and car seat recalls (2022)
- UPPAbaby stroller and car seat recalls (2022)
- Maxi Cosi Pria 85 recall (2021)
Consider taking unused products to the Target Car Seat Trade-In Program (a 2-week event usually in April and September) to swap your used items with a 20% discount coupon for various baby essentials.
References
(1) https://www.chicco.ca/en/safety-advisories/2018-08-10/Keyfit-30-Infant-Car-Seats
(2) https://www.consumerreports.org/cro/news/2008/06/chicco-recalls-18-000-infant-safety-seats/index.htm
(3) https://recalls.gracobaby.com/products/CS16XTFCNV.html
(4) https://edition.cnn.com/2014/02/11/us/graco-child-seat-recall/index.html
(5) https://www.businesswire.com/news/home/20230308005900/en/Settlement-Administrator-Angeion-Group-announces-Proposed-Settlement-in-Chicco-%E2%80%9CKidFit%E2%80%9D-Booster-Seat-Class-Action
