Fertility

Best Pull-Ups: What Are The Best Diapers For Big Kids & Potty Training?

Updated on 16 April 2022 • 23 minute read

 

Are Pull-Ups As Good As Diapers? 

Is your little one ready for potty training? You might want to choose pull-ups and training pants instead of regular diapers

Pull-ups are a type of diaper designed for big kids. Rather than the usual adhesive tabs or velcro straps, pull-ups have a similar design to underwear with stretchy waistbands but more absorbency.

Many parents notice that pull-ups may be less absorbent than regular diapers. 

Pull-ups can be more prone to leaking because they don’t hold up as much as traditional baby diapers. But they’re usually introduced around the time you start potty training. So, your baby might no longer need them if the training is successful.

The best pull-up diapers can help older kids transition from diapers to underwear. But which one should you choose? What are their best features? How will you know when it’s time to use pull-ups instead of diapers? Find out below.

 

Best Pull-Ups: Main Differences & Similarities

Disposable Pull-Up Diapers

  • Eco by Naty Pull-on Pants
  • Dyper Briefs
  • Eco Pea Bamboo Potty Training Diapers
  • Rascal + Friends Premium Training Pants
  • Hello Bello Training Pants
  • Seventh Generation Training Pants
  • GoodNites Bedtime Pants
  • Pampers Easy Ups Training Pants
  • Pampers Ninjamas
  • Huggies Little Movers Slip-On Diaper Pants
  • Huggies Pull-Ups Training Pants
  • Huggies Pull-Ups New Leaf
  • Honest Company Toddler Training Pants
  • Bambo Nature Dream Training Pants
  • Parent’s Choice by Walmart Training Pants
  • Up & Up by Target

 

Reusable Pull-Ups

  • Thirsties Reusable Cloth Potty Training Pant 
  • MooMoo Kow Baby Potty Training Pants
  • Charlie Banana Training Pants With Snaps

 

Similarities

  • Sizes that depend on your baby’s body weight, not their waistline
  • Underwear-like design
  • Less absorbency than regular diapers

 

Differences: Disposable Pull-Up Diapers

Eco by Naty Pull-on Pants

  • Smallest size: Size 4 (18-33 lbs), 22 count: $13.49 
  • Smallest size: $0.61 per diaper
  • Biggest size: Size 6 (35+ lbs), 18 count: $17.52
  • Biggest size: $0.97 per diaper
  • Made of plant-based, plastic-free material
  • Hypoallergenic and free from toxic chemicals
  • Nature-inspired design
  • ASTM D6866 eco-certification for eco-friendly products
  • OEKO-TEX Standard 100 certification for being free from toxic chemicals such as dioxins, perfume or fragrances, phthalates, dyes, latex, GMOs (genetically modified organisms), chlorine, lotions, VOCs (volatile organic compounds), parabens, and HAP (hazardous air pollutants). (1)
  • Eco-certified by TÜV Austria (independent testing authority)
  • VEGAN V-Label by the European Vegetarian Union, which means that they’re free from animal ingredients and weren’t tested on animals (2)
  • Save 10% on subscription options

 

Dyper Briefs

  • Smallest size: M (13-24 lb), 25 briefs/bag: $24.99 
  • Smallest size: $1.00 per diaper
  • Biggest size: XXL (38+ lb), 25 briefs/bag: $24.99 
  • Biggest size: $1.00 per diaper
  • Bamboo fiber, bioplastic, with elemental chlorine-free wood pulp
  • Hypoallergenic, unprinted, unscented, and cruelty-free
  • OEKO-TEX Standard 100 certification. 
  • Resealable sides
  • Subscription options available 
  • Disposal service available

 

Eco Pea Bamboo Potty Training Diapers

  • Smallest size: Size 3 (21-31 lbs), 20 pcs: $14.99
  • Smallest size: $0.75 per diaper
  • Biggest size: Size 4 (28-44 lbs), 18 pcs: $14.99
  • Biggest size: $0.83 per diaper
  • Hypoallergenic, dermatologist-tested pull-ups made of bamboo
  • Snug-fitting technology with blowout guard
  • Free from fragrances, chlorine, gluten, or any harsh chemicals
  • Vegan and cruelty-free (not tested on animals)
  • Biodegradable packaging
  • Subscription options available (20% off)

 

Rascal + Friends Premium Training Pants

  • Smallest size: Size 3 (20-34 lbs), 140 pcs: $39.35
  • Smallest size: $0.28 per diaper
  • Biggest size: Size 6 (35+ lbs), 76 pcs: $29.97
  • Biggest size: $0.39 per diaper
  • Dermatologically tested
  • Deep pocket and double leak guards that may help prevent overflow
  • Free from lotions, chlorine, fragrance, glyphosate, latex, and other harsh chemicals
  • OEKO-TEX certified 
  • Certified vegan and cruelty-free

 

Hello Bello Training Pants

  • Smallest size: Size 2T-3T (18-34 lbs), 25 pcs: $8.99
  • Smallest size: $0.36 per diaper
  • Biggest size: Size 12M-24M, 27 pcs: $8.99
  • Biggest size: $0.33
  • Chlorine-free fluff pulp from plant-based sources
  • Free from toxic chemicals like latex, phthalates, chlorine processing, TBT (tributyltin), DBT (dibutyltin), and MBT (monobutyltin)
  • Hypoallergenic
  • Cute prints

 

Seventh Generation Training Pants

  • Smallest size: Size 2T-3T (up to 34 lbs), 100 pcs: $44.94
  • Smallest size: $0.45 per diaper
  • Biggest size: Size 4T-5T (38+ lbs), 68 pcs: $49.96
  • Biggest size: $0.73 per diaper
  • Chlorine-free absorbent core made of processed wood fluff pulp
  • Hypoallergenic 
  • Cute designs
  • Climate Pledge Friendly manufacturer

 

GoodNites Bedtime Pants

  • Smallest size: XS (28-43 lbs), 44 pcs: $28.12
  • Smallest size: $0.64 per diaper
  • Biggest size: X-large (95-140 lbs), 28 pcs: $28.12
  • Biggest size: $1.00 per diaper
  • Five layers of absorbency
  • Biggest size available (may fit adults)
  • Odor-absorbing bedwetting underwear
  • Gender-based options, with zone protection for areas where boys or girls need it most

 

Pampers Easy Ups Training Pants

  • Smallest size: Size 2T-3T (16-34 lbs), 140 pcs: $45.94
  • Smallest size: $0.33 per diaper
  • Biggest size: Size 5T-6T, 84 pcs: $45.94
  • Biggest size: $0.55 per diaper
  • Absorbent wood pulp
  • Free from latex, parabens, and chlorine
  • Cute cartoon prints
  • Dual leak-guard barriers

 

Pampers Ninjamas

  • Smallest size: S/M (38-65 lbs), 44 pcs: $26.94
  • Smallest size: $0.61 per diaper
  • Biggest size: L/XL (64-125 lbs), 34 pcs: $26.46
  • Biggest size: $0.78 per diaper
  • Quiet-cloth material
  • Free from parabens, chlorine, and latex
  • All-night leak protection
  • Marketed by the brand as ideal nighttime underwear for heavy wetters
  • Odormask technology

 

Huggies Little Movers Slip-On Diaper Pants

  • Smallest size: Size 3 (16-28 lbs), 156 pcs: $48.80
  • Smallest size: $0.31 per diaper
  • Biggest size: Size 7 (41+ lbs), 80 pcs: $59.98
  • Biggest size: $0.75 per diaper
  • Superabsorbent wood fluff pulp core
  • Leak Lock System
  • Free from natural rubber latex, chlorine, lotion, and fragrance
  • Huggies’ SizeUp indicator can help you determine if your baby needs to wear the next size

 

Huggies Pull-Ups Training Pants

  • Smallest size: Size 2T-3T (16-34 lbs), 124 pcs: $45.18
  • Smallest size: $0.36 per diaper
  • Biggest size: Size 4T-5T (38-50 lbs), 99 pcs: $45.23
  • Biggest size: $0.46 per diaper
  • Hypoallergenic
  • Soft, refastenable sides
  • The brand claims that this pull-up diaper is clinically proven to be hypoallergenic.
  • Gender-based protection to ensure added absorbency at parts where boys or girls need most 
  • May feel like underwear for big kids.

 

Huggies Pull-Ups New Leaf

  • Smallest size: Size 2T-3T (16-34 lbs), 88 pcs: $34.98
  • Smallest size: $0.40 per diaper
  • Biggest size: Size 4T-5T (38-50 lbs), 66 pcs: $35.33
  • Biggest size: $0.54 per diaper
  • Plant-based material
  • Hypoallergenic
  • The brand claims that it’s clinically proven to be hypoallergenic.
  • Designed to look like underwear
  • Cute Disney prints
  • Marketed as the brand’s softest training pants

 

Honest Company Toddler Training Pants

  • Smallest size: Size 2T-3T (up to 34 lbs), 26 pcs: $10.95
  • Smallest size: $0.42 per diaper
  • Biggest size: Size 4T-5T (38+ lbs), 19 pcs: $10.95
  • Biggest size: $0.58 per diaper
  • Sustainably harvested wood pulp and plant-derived materials
  • Free from chlorine
  • Liquid-locking core with secure-fitting moisture barrier cuffs
  • Designed like underwear

 

Bambo Nature Dream Training Pants

  • Smallest size: Size 4 (15-31 lbs), 22 pcs: $12.50
  • Smallest size: $0.57 per diaper
  • Biggest size: Size 6 (40+ lbs), 19 pcs: $12.50
  • Biggest size: $0.66 per diaper
  • Certified eco-friendly, TCF (totally chlorine-free) wood pulp
  • Certified skin-safe
  • The brand claims that these pull-ups are certified skin-safe and free from harmful chemicals or allergens.
  • Subscription options are available.

 

Parent’s Choice by Walmart Training Pants

  • Smallest size: Size 2T-3T (up to 34 lbs), 94 pcs: $25.12
  • Smallest size: $0.27 per diaper
  • Biggest size: Size 4T-5T (38+ lbs), 70 pcs: $25.12
  • Biggest size: $0.36 per diaper
  • May absorb up to 10x its own weight
  • Cute designs
  • Costs much less than the leading brands

 

Up & Up by Target

  • Smallest size: Size 2T-3T (up to 34 lbs), 28 pcs: $7.99
  • Smallest size: $0.29 per diaper
  • Biggest size: Size 4T-5T (up to 50 lbs), 19 pcs: $7.99
  • Biggest size: $0.42 per diaper
  • Polypropylene, cloth-like cover
  • Elastic stretch sides with reclosable velcro
  • Underwear-like fit
  • Printed patterns (choices available for boys and girls)
  • Much cheaper than pull-ups from leading name brands

 

Differences: Reusable Pull-Ups

Thirsties Reusable Cloth Potty Training Pant 

  • Smallest size: Small (20-27 lbs), one piece: $20.25
  • Biggest size: X-large (42-56+ lbs), one piece: $21.75
  • Reusable potty training pants
  • Organic cotton absorbent layer, with a polyester outer layer
  • GOTS certified organic cotton, a certification for organic products free from toxic chemicals (3)
  • Wet zone with waterproof TPU (thermoplastic polyurethane) laminate that may help keep your baby’s clothes dry
  • Machine washable

 

MooMoo Kow Baby Potty Training Pants

  • One size fits all (3-5 years old), one training pants: $35
  • Soft bamboo with absorbent padding and waterproof outer layer
  • Comfortable fit if adjusted to your baby’s size (adjustable with snaps)
  • Reusable training underwear
  • May be thinner than other cloth diapers
  • With adjustable snaps so your pull-ups can grow with your baby
  • Machine washable
  • Dryer safe or hung to dry
  • Cute prints

 

Charlie Banana Training Pants With Snaps

  • Smallest size: Small (10-14 lbs), one piece: $12.99
  • Biggest size: X-large (27-44 lbs), one piece: $14.99
  • Cheaper than the other reusable training pants
  • Waterproof outer cover with organic cotton inner lining
  • Cute prints
  • Climate Neutral Certified
  • Machine washable

 

Learn more about each pull-up diaper below.

 

Eco by Naty Pull-on Pants

Price

  • Size 4 (18-33 lbs), 22 count: $13.49
  • Size 5 (26-40 lbs), 80 count: $53.96
  • Size 6 (35+ lbs), 18 count: $17.52

 

Key Features

  • Material: Plant-based, plastic-free material
  • Product Safety: Hypoallergenic, free from harsh chemicals and skin irritants to minimize the risks of diaper rash and allergies
  • Size Range: Sizes 4 to 6
  • Fit: Comfortable fit
  • Absorbency: Absorbent core
  • Wetness Indicator: None
  • Umbilical Cord Notch: None
  • Hours of Protection: Not indicated

 

Other Special Features:

  • Nature-inspired design
  • Soft, thin, and breathable
  • Dermatologically tested
  • ASTM D6866 eco-certification for eco-friendly products
  • OEKO-TEX Standard 100 certification for being free from toxic chemicals such as dioxins, perfume or fragrances, phthalates, dyes, latex, GMOs (genetically modified organisms), chlorine, lotions, VOCs (volatile organic compounds), parabens, and HAP (hazardous air pollutants). (1)
  • Eco-certified by TÜV Austria (independent testing authority)
  • VEGAN V-Label by the European Vegetarian Union, which means that they’re free from animal ingredients and weren’t tested on animals (2)
  • Subscription options are available at 10% off

 

Product Recall

  • None

 

Cons

  • Doesn’t have a wetness indicator

 

What Customers Say

Positive Reviews 

They are soft and comfortable and they hold heavy night time wetting well.” – Reviewer on Amazon.

Negative Reviews 

They are now made in CHINA, they smell like chemicals, and the new design is totally different – like a cheesy commercial diaper. The quality sucks now. And — the price is just as high as when they were made in Finland with quality materials.” – Reviewer on Amazon.

 

Dyper Briefs

Price

  • 25 briefs/bag: $24.99 for all sizes

 

Sizes available:

  • M: 13-24 lb 
  • L: 21-31 lb
  • XL: 28-38 lb
  • XXL: 38+ lb

 

Key Features

  • Material: Bamboo fiber, bioplastic, elemental chlorine-free wood pulp, and sodium polyacrylate (absorbent polymer commonly used in diapers)
  • Product Safety: Hypoallergenic, unprinted, unscented, and cruelty-free
  • Size Range: M (13-24 lb) to XXL (38+ lb)
  • Fit: Skinny fit
  • Absorbency: Soft and absorbent
  • Wetness Indicator: Yes
  • Umbilical Cord Notch: None
  • Hours of Protection: Not indicated

 

Other Special Features: 

  • OEKO-TEX Standard 100 certification for being free from toxic chemicals such as dioxins, lotions, perfume or fragrances, phthalates, dyes, latex, GMOs (genetically modified organisms), chlorine, VOCs (volatile organic compounds), parabens, and HAP (hazardous air pollutants). 
  • Resealable sides
  • Subscription options available 
  • Disposal service available

 

Product Recall

  • None

 

Cons

  • Some parents complain about the diapers being too small and too thin.
  • Doesn’t have an indicator of which side is front or back
  • Plain diapers with no prints

 

What Customers Say

Positive Reviews 

They work really well, and no spillage.” – Reviewer on Amazon.

Negative Reviews 

They are cut very narrow, so when our daughter would move so would the sides so she would leak. If they did catch her accidents they were very absorbent but with how bad they moved it wasn’t very often.” – Reviewer on Amazon.

 

Eco Pea Bamboo Potty Training Diapers

Price

  • Size 3 (21-31 lbs), 20 pcs: $14.99
  • Size 4 (28-44 lbs), 18 pcs: $14.99

 

Key Features

  • Material: Bamboo
  • Product Safety: Hypoallergenic, dermatologist-tested pull-ups
  • Size Range: Size 3 (21-31 lbs) to Size 4 (28-44 lbs)
  • Fit: Snug-fitting technology
  • Wetness Indicator: Yes
  • Leak Protection: Blowout guard
  • Umbilical Cord Notch: None
  • Hours of Protection: Not indicated

 

Other Special Features:

  • Free from fragrances, chlorine, or any harsh chemicals
  • Water-based ink
  • Vegan and cruelty-free (not tested on animals)
  • Biodegradable packaging
  • Subscription options are available at 20% off

 

Product Recall

  • None

 

Cons

  • Limited diaper sizes
  • Only one design available (no cute prints)

 

What Customers Say

Positive Reviews 

They are sturdy, do not leak, and we find the fit better than other brands, keeping in a lot of pee and preventing blowouts.” – Reviewer on Eco Pea’s website.

Negative Reviews 

My son pees out of them after only peeing one time. I got the size that was in his weight limit and I feel like they are still too big and that’s why he pees out.” – Reviewer on Eco Pea’s website.

 

Rascal + Friends Premium Training Pants

Price

  • Size 3 (20-34 lbs), 140 pcs: $39.35
  • Size 4 (22-33 lbs), 96 pcs: $29.97
  • Size 5 (28-39 lbs), 84 pcs: $29.97
  • Size 6 (35+ lbs), 76 pcs: $29.97

 

Key Features

  • Material: Feather-soft plant-based pulp, polypropylene non-woven fabric, polyethylene film, and SAP (super absorbent material)
  • Product Safety: Dermatologically tested
  • Size Range: Size 
  • Fit: Soft, curved leg cuff and stretchy waistband for a comfortable fit
  • Absorbency: Three layers of protection
  • Wetness Indicator: None
  • Leak Protection: Deep pocket and double leak guards that may help prevent overflow
  • Air Channels: Breathable back sheets
  • Umbilical Cord Notch: None
  • Hours of Protection: May offer up to 12 hours of leak protection

 

Other Special Features:

  • Free from lotions, chlorine, fragrance, glyphosate, latex, and other harsh chemicals
  • OEKO-TEX certified 
  • Certified vegan and cruelty-free
  • Soft 3D core that may provide extra absorbency and comfort
  • Easy-tear sides
  • Resealable tab
  • Cute designs

 

Product Recall

  • None

 

Cons

  • Doesn’t have a printed indicator of which side is front or back
  • Doesn’t have a wetness indicator
  • May be bulkier than other diapers

 

What Customers Say

Positive Reviews 

The ultimate stay dry diaper – Material of the gods – The beads NEVER come off onto the baby no matter if I don’t change her right away like they do with other diapers – You really don’t have to change them too often thus saving your money – No weird odor whatsoever – No leaking EVER.” – Reviewer on Walmart.

Negative Reviews 

These smell funky when they get the slightest bit of urine in them, however that is the only thing that lets me know my toddler has peed in them. They are so dense and thick I cannot tell when my toddler has peed in them by squeezing the diaper.” – Reviewer on Walmart.

 

Hello Bello Training Pants

Price

  • Size 2T-3T (18-34 lbs), 25 pcs: $8.99
  • Size 3T-4T (32-40 lbs), 22 pcs: $8.99
  • Size 4T-5T (38+ lbs), 18 pcs: $8.99
  • Size 12M-24M, 27 pcs: $8.99

 

Key Features

  • Material: Chlorine-free fluff pulp from plant-based sources, spherical super absorbent polymer (commonly used in diapers), polypropylene/polyethylene/polyester non-woven fibers, and plant-derived PLA non-woven fiber
  • Product Safety: Free from toxic chemicals like latex, phthalates, chlorine processing, TBT (tributyltin), DBT (dibutyltin), and MBT (monobutyltin)
  • Size Range: Size 2T-3T (18-34 lbs) to Size 12M-24M
  • Fit: Slim fit
  • Absorbency: Absorbent material
  • Wetness Indicator: None
  • Leak Protection: Premium leg cuffs may prevent leakage
  • Umbilical Cord Notch: None
  • Hours of Protection: Not indicated

 

Other Special Features:

  • Hypoallergenic
  • Free from lotion and artificial fragrance
  • Cute prints

 

Product Recall

  • None

 

Cons

  • Some complaints about absorbency and leaking

 

What Customers Say

Positive Reviews 

Very strong pull-ups they don’t ripped easily like others brand also have the tape to close the diaper.” – Reviewer on Walmart.

Negative Reviews 

While they are soft and have cute prints my daughter leaks really bad in these. we have never had an issue with any other brand.” – Reviewer on Walmart.

 

Seventh Generation Training Pants

Price

  • Size 2T-3T (up to 34 lbs), 100 pcs: $44.94
  • Size 3T-4T (32-40 lbs), 88 pcs: $49.96
  • Size 4T-5T (38+ lbs), 68 pcs: $49.96

 

Key Features

  • Material: Chlorine-free absorbent core made of processed wood fluff pulp and sodium polyacrylate, polypropylene, adhesives, polymer spandex, and pigments or inks for external prints
  • Product Safety: Made for sensitive skin and free from fragrance, chlorine bleaching, or lotions
  • Size Range: Size 2T-3T (up to 34 lbs) to Size 4T-5T (38+ lbs)
  • Fit: Stretchy sides
  • Wetness Indicator: None
  • Umbilical Cord Notch: None
  • Hours of Protection: Not indicated

 

Other Special Features:

  • Hypoallergenic 
  • Easy to tell front from back
  • Tear-away side panels
  • Climate Pledge Friendly manufacturer
  • Cute designs

 

Product Recall

  • None

 

Cons

  • More expensive than other brands
  • Many parents complain about leakage

 

What Customers Say

Positive Reviews 

I highly recommend these when your child is around 2 and is more aware of telling you that they have gone pee. They hold around 1-2 urinations.” – Reviewer on Amazon.

Negative Reviews 

We used them at night for daytime potty-trained toddler. He peed even a little and he was soaked.” – Reviewer on Amazon.

 

GoodNites Bedtime Pants

Price

  • XS (28-43 lbs), 44 pcs: $28.12
  • S/M (43-68 lbs), 22 pcs (pack of two): $28.12
  • L (68-95 lbs), 34 pcs: $32.99
  • X-large (95-140 lbs), 28 pcs: $28.12

 

Key Features

  • Material: No information
  • Product Safety: No information
  • Size Range: Big sizes for up to X-large (95-140 lbs)
  • Fit: Stretchy sides for a perfect fit
  • Absorbency: Five layers of absorbency
  • Wetness Indicator: None
  • Leak Protection: Double leg barriers
  • Umbilical Cord Notch: None
  • Hours of Protection: Designed for overnight use

 

Other Special Features:

  • Odor-absorbing bedwetting underwear
  • Gender-based options, with zone protection for areas where boys or girls need it most
  • Cute Disney designs for girls (Moana and Ariel)
  • Cute Marvel designs for boys (Spiderman and Hulk)
  • Large sizes that may be ideal for older children and even adults

 

Product Recall

  • None

 

Cons

  • Some kids complain about the pull-ups being uncomfortable.
  • Limited information on the material used and product safety

 

What Customers Say

Positive Reviews 

Not only did it stop the over urine from leaking, he can even wear it a few hours after waking and it’s still good! AMAZING!” – Reviewer on Amazon.

Negative Reviews 

At first I thought my son was just being picky and toddler-dramatic…but from the first new pull up, he would fuss around with it, once he even took it off in his sleep!” – Reviewer on Amazon.

 

Pampers Easy Ups Training Pants

Price

  • Size 2T-3T (16-34 lbs), 140 pcs: $45.94
  • Size 3T-4T (30-40 lbs), 124 pcs: $45.94
  • Size 4T-5T (38+ lbs), 104 pcs: $45.94
  • Size 5T-6T, 84 pcs: $45.94

 

Key Features

  • Material: Absorbent wood pulp, polypropylene, polyethylene, and spandex
  • Product Safety: Hypoallergenic and dermatologically tested
  • Size Range: Sizes 2T to 6T
  • Fit: 360-degree Stretchy waistband
  • Absorb Channels: Extra absorb channels that may prevent leaks day and night
  • Wetness Indicator: Yes, pH-sensitive material that changes color
  • Leak Protection: Dual leak-guard barriers
  • Umbilical Cord Notch: None
  • Hours of Protection: Not indicated

 

Other Special Features:

  • Free from latex, parabens, and chlorine
  • Easy-tear sides
  • Cute cartoon prints

 

Product Recall

  • None

 

Cons

  • Some parents complain about their kids experiencing irritation, possibly due to this product’s fragrance.

 

What Customers Say

Positive Reviews 

This pull ups really works wonders, it’s light weight and breathable during the summer not as hot for the babies/toddlers like regular diapers during the summer months.” – Reviewer on Walmart.

Negative Reviews 

These left horrible, bloody rashes and hives on both of my kids. Both my children wore nothing but pampers swaddlers their entire lives but the second they switched to the easy ups they broke out in horrible rashes.” – Reviewer on Amazon.

 

Pampers Ninjamas

Price

  • S/M (38-65 lbs), 44 pcs: $26.94
  • L/XL (64-125 lbs), 34 pcs: $26.46

 

Key Features

  • Material: Quiet-cloth material
  • Product Safety: Free from parabens, chlorine, and latex
  • Size Range: Small (38-65 lbs) to XL (64-125 lbs)
  • Fit: Form-fitting 360-degree waistband
  • Absorb Channels: Lockaway channels that may absorb wetness quickly and keep it away from your baby’s skin
  • Wetness Indicator: None
  • Leak Protection: All-night leak protection
  • Air Channels: Breathable
  • Umbilical Cord Notch: None
  • Hours of Protection: Not indicated

 

Other Special Features:

  • Marketed by the brand as ideal nighttime underwear for heavy wetters
  • Odormask technology

 

Product Recall

  • None

 

Cons

  • Some parents complain about leakage.

 

What Customers Say

Positive Reviews 

Honestly, those panties retain almost everything, even when it’s a big accident: no leak!” – Reviewer on Ninjamas’ website.

Negative Reviews 

My husband bought these for our 3yr daughter to wear to bed because we are potty training…They are horrible she has leaked thru them during the night.” – Reviewer on Ninjamas’ website.

 

Huggies Little Movers Slip-On Diaper Pants

Price

  • Size 3 (16-28 lbs), 156 pcs: $48.80
  • Size 4 (22-37 lbs), 140 pcs: $50.44
  • Size 5 (27+ lbs), 120 pcs: $49.99
  • Size 6 (35+ lbs), 96 pcs: $49.70
  • Size 7 (41+ lbs), 80 pcs: $59.98

 

Key Features

  • Material: Superabsorbent wood fluff pulp core, sodium polyacrylate, polypropylene, and polyethylene
  • Product Safety: Hypoallergenic, fragrance-free
  • Size Range: From sizes 3 (16-28 lbs) to 7 (41+ lbs)
  • Fit: Stretchy back waistband
  • Absorbency: Fast-absorbing liner
  • Wetness Indicator: Yes
  • Leak Protection: Leak Lock System
  • Air Channels: Breathable
  • Umbilical Cord Notch: None
  • Hours of Protection: May work up to 12 hours

 

Other Special Features:

  • Free from natural rubber latex, chlorine, lotion, and fragrance
  • Double grip strips
  • Huggies’ SizeUp indicator can help you determine if your baby needs to wear the next size.

 

Product Recall

  • None

 

Cons

  • Some parents complain about skin irritation.

 

What Customers Say

Positive Reviews 

I have twin girls who are getting interested in potty training. The slip-on diapers are convenient for the times they want to “try” to use the potty but also very absorbent and leak proof!” – Reviewer on Huggies’ website.

Negative Reviews 

Bought them as my son is a busy boy! He wears size 4 in little movers and was advised to stay the same size in the slip on. Absolutely horrible. They have left red blotches on his sides where the diaper sits and now I’m stuck with 2 unopened sleeves!” – Reviewer on Huggies’ website.

 

Huggies Pull-Ups Training Pants

Price

  • Size 2T-3T (16-34 lbs), 124 pcs: $45.18
  • Size 3T-4T (32-40 lbs), 112 pcs: $45.35
  • Size 4T-5T (38-50 lbs), 99 pcs: $45.23

 

Key Features

  • Material: Limited information
  • Product Safety: Hypoallergenic
  • Size Range: From 2T (16-34 lbs) to 5T (38-50 lbs)
  • Fit: Soft, refastenable sides
  • Absorbency: Not very absorbent
  • Wetness Indicator: Yes; special designs fade when wet
  • Leak Protection: Leak barriers
  • Air Channels: Breathable
  • Umbilical Cord Notch: None
  • Hours of Protection: Not indicated

 

Other Special Features:

  • The brand claims that this pull-up diaper is clinically proven to be hypoallergenic.
  • May feel like underwear for big kids
  • Gender-based protection to ensure added absorbency at parts where boys or girls need most 

 

Product Recall

  •  None

 

Cons

  • Limited information on what material is used to make this product, but the brand claims that the materials used in these pull-ups are thoroughly evaluated to be gentle on sensitive skin.
  • Some parents complain about the product leaking and not being very absorbent.

 

What Customers Say

Positive Reviews 

Great pull-up’s for special needs child. my special needs child ELIE is 5 years old and in diapers 24/7 due to his health problems. and I found that the HUGGIES pull-up‘s size 4t5t works great.” – Reviewer on Pull-Ups’ website.

Negative Reviews 

Not very absorbent. They are easy to use of course but they also gave my son a rash after using them. They’re just not that great.” – Reviewer on Pull-Ups’ website.

 

Huggies Pull-Ups New Leaf

Price

  • Size 2T-3T (16-34 lbs), 88 pcs: $34.98
  • Size 3T-4T (32-40 lbs), 78 pcs: $35.33
  • Size 4T-5T (38-50 lbs), 66 pcs: $35.33

 

Key Features

  • Material: Plant-based material
  • Product Safety: Hypoallergenic
  • Size Range: From 2T (16-34 lbs) to 5T (38-50 lbs)
  • Fit: Soft, refastenable sides
  • Wetness Indicator: Yes, the snowflake design fades when wet
  • Leak Protection: Leak protection barriers
  • Air Channels: Breathable 
  • Umbilical Cord Notch: None
  • Hours of Protection: Not indicated

 

Other Special Features:

  • The brand claims that it’s clinically proven to be hypoallergenic.
  • Marketed as the brand’s softest training pants
  • Designed to look like underwear
  • Cute Disney prints

 

Product Recall

  • None

 

Cons

  • Some parents complain about the product causing a rash on their children or having leakage issues.

 

What Customers Say

Positive Reviews 

My son has eczema and sensitive skin. The Huggies New Leaf pull-ups are the only diapers I can use for him because they are made with natural plant- based materials, soft cotton, & no harsh ingredients.” – Reviewer on Pull-ups’ website.

Negative Reviews 

Wasn’t soft, didn’t fit well, sides that tape together hung over the edge and cut into my sons legs. Very much didn’t like.” – Reviewer on Pull-ups’ website.

 

Honest Company Toddler Training Pants

Price

  • Size 2T-3T (up to 34 lbs), 26 pcs: $10.95
  • Size 3T-4T (32-40 lbs), 23 pcs: $10.95
  • Size 4T-5T (38+ lbs), 19 pcs: $10.95

 

Key Features

  • Material: Sustainably harvested wood pulp and plant-derived materials
  • Product Safety: Free from chlorine
  • Size Range: From 2T (16-34 lbs) to 5T (38-50 lbs)
  • Fit: Stretchy all-around waistband for a perfect fit
  • Absorbency: Liquid-locking core
  • Wetness Indicator: None
  • Leak Protection: Secure-fitting moisture barrier cuffs
  • Umbilical Cord Notch: None
  • Hours of Protection: Not indicated

 

Other Special Features:

  • Designed like underwear

 

Product Recall

  • None

 

Cons

  • Some parents complain about the sizes being smaller than other brands.

 

What Customers Say

Positive Reviews 

My Son is obsessed with trucks so the design was perfect! They are very soft & easy to pull up and down, not too tight.” – Reviewer on Honest Company’s website.

Negative Reviews 

“The don’t hold much urine and are basically thongs for babies. My poor boy has an all day wedgie with these terrible things. They are so stiff and rip easily as well. Terrible material and terrible design. Only good thing was the tractor print.” – Reviewer on Honest Company’s website.

 

Bambo Nature Training Pants

Price

  • Size 4 (15-31 lbs), 22 pcs: $12.50
  • Size 5 (27-40 lbs), 20 pcs: $12.50
  • Size 6 (40+ lbs), 19 pcs: $12.50

 

Key Features

  • Material: Certified eco-friendly, TCF (totally chlorine-free) wood pulp
  • Product Safety: Certified skin-safe
  • Size Range: Sizes 4 (15-31 lbs) to 6 (40+ lbs)
  • Fit: Flexible and may be easy to pull up
  • Absorbency: Three layers of absorbency
  • Wetness Indicator: None
  • Leak Protection: Leakage barrier
  • Air Channels: Breathable
  • Umbilical Cord Notch: None
  • Hours of Protection: May last overnight

 

Other Special Features:

  • The brand claims that these pull-ups are certified skin-safe and free from harmful chemicals or allergens.
  • Thinner design
  • Subscription options are available

 

Product Recall

  •  None

 

Cons

  • Sizes may be smaller than those from leading brands
  • May be prone to leaking

 

What Customers Say

Positive Reviews 

Best diapers/training pants I’ve ever tried. Fit well, eco-friendly, and easy design for my little one to pull up herself. My go to diapers. Also, affordable compared to some other brands. No rash problem (except if I forget to change it). Thanks Bambo!” – Reviewer on Bambo Nature USA’s website.

Negative Reviews 

My daughter used those diapers just 2 nights and I need to wash my whole bed again because it is wet but diaper is dry.” – Reviewer on Bambo Nature USA’s website.

 

Parent’s Choice (by Walmart) Training Pants

Price

  • Size 2T-3T (up to 34 lbs), 94 pcs: $25.12
  • Size 3T-4T (32-40 lbs), 86 pcs: $25.12
  • Size 4T-5T (38+ lbs), 70 pcs: $25.12

 

Key Features

  • Material: Limited information
  • Product Safety: Limited information
  • Size Range: Size 2T (up to 34 lbs) to 5T (38+ lbs)
  • Fit: Snug fit
  • Absorbency: May absorb up to 10x its own weight
  • Wetness Indicator: Yes
  • Leak Protection: Leak guards
  • Air Channels: Breathable 
  • Umbilical Cord Notch: None
  • Hours of Protection: Not indicated

 

Other Special Features:

  • Opens easily at the sides
  • Cute designs
  • Costs much less than the leading brands

 

Product Recall

  • None

 

Cons

  • Limited information about the product’s safety and materials used
  • May be more prone to leaking

 

What Customers Say

Positive Reviews 

They’re easy to put on, good quality, and very cute design. You can easily open the sides in case your little has a no-no accident. And you can easily open the sides and stick the sides together if it’s more convenient than pulling them up.” – Reviewer on Walmart.

Negative Reviews 

They are awful. They don’t have 1/4 of the wetness control padding that Huggies pull ups have. It doesn’t pay to buy these when you have to change them more frequently. And don’t even think about using them at nap time. The poor boy was a soggy, wet mess.” – Reviewer on Walmart.

 

Up & Up By Target

Price

  • Size 2T-3T (up to 34 lbs), 28 pcs: $7.99
  • Size 3T-4T (up to 40 lbs), 24 pcs: $7.99
  • Size 4T-5T (up to 50 lbs), 19 pcs: $7.99

 

Key Features

  • Material: Polypropylene, cloth-like cover
  • Product Safety: Fragrance-free
  • Size Range: From sizes 2T (up to 34 lbs) to 5T (up to 50 lbs)
  • Fit: Elastic stretch sides with reclosable velcro
  • Absorbency: Absorbent core 
  • Wetness Indicator: Yes
  • Leak Protection: Double leg barrier
  • Air Channels: Breathable
  • Umbilical Cord Notch: None
  • Hours of Protection: Not indicated

 

Other Special Features:

  • Easy-open sides
  • Underwear-like fit
  • Printed patterns (choices available for boys and girls)
  • Much cheaper than pull-ups from leading name brands

Product Recall

  • None

 

Cons

  • May be more prone to leaking

 

What Customers Say

Positive Reviews 

Up&up are by far the best brand of diapers and pull ups around. We’ve never had leaking like with other name brands and the cost of up & up can’t be beat! Plus my daughter loves the dinosaurs! Thank you for providing an affordable and quality product!” – Reviewer on Target.

Negative Reviews 

I normally buy pull-ups from a competitor, and I have been doing a lot of shopping at target so I thought I would give their brand a try. Never again will I buy target brand pull-ups. They do not last very long and I have had to end up changing my daughters clothes due to leakage more times than I want. Not very practical when you are in public and you have to change clothes because of this issue. Not happy with purchase and would never recommend target brand pull-ups to anyone!!!” – Reviewer on Target.

 

Thirsties Reusable Cloth Potty Training Pants

Price

  • Small (20-27 lbs), one piece: $20.25
  • Medium (26-35 lbs), one piece: $20.25
  • Large (33-45 lbs), one piece: $20.25
  • X-large (42-56+ lbs), one piece: $21.75

 

Key Features

  • Material: Organic cotton absorbent layer, with a polyester outer layer
  • Product Safety: GOTS certified organic cotton, a certification for organic products free from toxic chemicals (3)
  • Size Range: Small (20-27 lbs) to X-large (42-56+ lbs)
  • Fit: Snug, underwear-like fit
  • Absorbency: Four layers of absorbency
  • Absorb Channels: None
  • Wetness Indicator: None
  • Leak Protection: Gentle elastic material around leg hole
  • Air Channels: None
  • Umbilical Cord Notch: None
  • Hours of Protection: Not indicated

 

Other Special Features:

  • Reusable potty training pants
  • Wet zone with waterproof TPU (thermoplastic polyurethane) laminate that may help keep your baby’s clothes dry
  • Machine washable

 

Product Recall

  • None

 

Cons

  • It isn’t 100% organic.

 

What Customers Say

Positive Reviews 

We used the Oh Crap Method for both kids. These trainers were fantastic for the time after basics are learned! We used these instead of underwear for outings, long trips, even to the grocery store. The hemp absorbs a lot of liquid and can help with those leaks that might happen on the way to the toilet!” – Reviewer on Thirsties Baby’s website.

Negative Reviews 

The outer layer is folded into the inside and stitched meaning it isn’t just the organic cotton touching our kids skin. Sometimes I just don’t understand the point of all of that if they’re not gonna do it right. This is disappointing for Thirstiest especially for the price.” – Reviewer on Amazon.

 

MooMoo Kow Baby Potty Training Pants

Price

  • One size fits all (3-5 years old), one training pants: $35

 

Key Features

  • Material: Soft bamboo with absorbent padding and waterproof outer layer 
  • Size Range: One size only (adjustable with snaps)
  • Fit: Comfortable fit if adjusted to your baby’s size
  • Absorbency: Six layers of absorbency; but are designed to let toddlers feel the sensation of wetness
  • Absorb Channels: None
  • Wetness Indicator: None
  • Air Channels: Breathable
  • Umbilical Cord Notch: None
  • Hours of Protection: Not indicated

 

Other Special Features:

  • Reusable training underwear
  • May be thinner than other cloth diapers
  • With adjustable snaps so your pull-ups can grow with your baby
  • Machine washable
  • Dryer safe or can be hung to dry
  • Can be cost-effective because they’re reusable
  • Cute prints

 

Product Recall

  • None

 

Cons

  • Doesn’t have a lock-away core
  • Designed to let your toddler feel wetness, but may cause diaper rash if your child doesn’t let you know they wet their training pants
  • Limited reviews

 

Charlie Banana Training Pants With Snaps

Price

  • Small (10-14 lbs), one piece: $12.99
  • Medium (14-20  lbs), one piece: $12.99
  • Large (20-27 lbs), one piece: $13.99
  • X-large (27-44 lbs), one piece: $14.99

 

Key Features

  • Material: Waterproof outer cover with organic cotton inner lining
  • Product Safety: Organic cotton
  • Size Range: From small (10-14 lbs) to X-large (27-44 lbs)
  • Fit: Snug, underwear-like fit
  • Absorbency: Absorbent padding
  • Absorb Channels: None
  • Wetness Indicator: None
  • Leak Protection: Single barrier
  • Air Channels: None
  • Umbilical Cord Notch: None
  • Hours of Protection: Not indicated

 

Other Special Features:

  • Reusable training pants
  • Climate Neutral Certified
  • Machine wash cold
  • Cute prints
  • Cheaper than the other reusable training pants

 

Product Recall

  • None

 

Cons

  • May be prone to leaking
  • May be smaller than diapers from leading brands

 

What Customers Say

Positive Reviews 

We loved having those when Our son potty train – highly recommend. Organic and soft.” – Reviewer on Charlie Banana’s website.

Negative Reviews 

These are not waterproof at all. Pee goes right through them. They would probably hold a poop accident in for a little while but they do nothing for pee. We will have to use them as swim diapers. They are really thin with virtually no padding, so I should have figured they wouldn’t work. Oh well, I guess the car seat needed to be washed. I am really disappointed because my daughter weighs 19 pounds and the smallest pull-ups are huge and bulky, and these are not. I thought these would be the solution to the bulkiness for times we leave the house and need a back-up.” – Reviewer on Charlie Banana’s website.

 

Summary & Recommendation 

Pull-up diapers can be handy baby products to help your little transition from regular diapers to underwear. But all pull-ups aren’t created equal.

Here are our recommendations to help you choose the right ones for your baby:

 

Choose Eco by Naty Pull-on Pants if you prefer:

  • High-quality organic diapers with several safety certifications (ASTM D6866 eco-certification, OEKO-TEX Standard 100 certification, eco-certification by TÜV Austria, and VEGAN V-Label by the European Vegetarian Union)
  • Value-friendly prices than other organic diaper options (smallest size: $0.61 per diaper; biggest size: $0.97 per diaper)
  • Plant-based, plastic-free pull-ups
  • Hypoallergenic and free from toxic chemicals
  • Nature-inspired design
  • Subscription options (10% off)

 

Choose Dyper Briefs if you prefer:

  • Bamboo fiber, bioplastic pull-ups with elemental chlorine-free wood pulp
  • Hypoallergenic, unprinted, unscented, and cruelty-free diapers
  • OEKO-TEX Standard 100 certification 
  • Resealable sides
  • Subscription and disposal service options
  • Don’t mind the high price tag ($1.00 per diaper for all sizes)

 

Choose Eco Pea Bamboo Potty Training Diapers if you prefer:

  • Hypoallergenic, dermatologist-tested pull-ups made of bamboo
  • Snug-fitting technology with blowout guard
  • Pull-ups free from fragrances, chlorine, or any harsh chemicals
  • Vegan and cruelty-free (not tested on animals) products
  • Biodegradable packaging
  • Subscription options available (20% off)

 

Choose Rascal + Friends Premium Training Pants if you prefer:

  • Dermatologically tested
  • Deep pocket and double leak guards that may help prevent overflow
  • Free from lotions, chlorine, fragrance, glyphosate, latex, and other harsh chemicals
  • Certified vegan and cruelty-free
  • Value-friendly pull-ups with OEKO-TEX certification (smallest size: $0.28 per diaper; biggest size: $0.39 per diaper)

 

Choose Hello Bello Training Pants if you prefer:

  • Chlorine-free fluff pulp from plant-based sources
  • Pull-ups free from toxic chemicals like latex, phthalates, chlorine processing, TBT (tributyltin), DBT (dibutyltin), and MBT (monobutyltin)
  • Hypoallergenic diapers
  • Cute prints

 

Choose Seventh Generation Training Pants if you prefer:

  • Hypoallergenic pull-ups 
  • Chlorine-free absorbent core made of processed wood fluff pulp
  • Cute designs
  • Climate Pledge Friendly manufacturer

 

Choose GoodNites Bedtime Pants if you prefer:

  • Five layers of absorbency
  • Biggest size available (may fit adults)
  • Odor-absorbing bedwetting underwear
  • Gender-based options (with zone protection for areas where boys or girls need it most)
  • Don’t mind the higher price tag (smallest size: $0.64 per diaper; biggest size: $1.00 per diaper)

 

Choose Pampers Easy Ups Training Pants if you prefer:

  • Pull-ups made of absorbent wood pulp
  • Free from latex, parabens, and chlorine
  • Cute cartoon prints
  • Dual leak-guard barriers

 

Choose Pampers Ninjamas if you prefer:

  • Quiet-cloth material
  • Free from parabens, chlorine, and latex
  • All-night leak protection
  • Pull-up marketed as ideal nighttime underwear for heavy wetters
  • Odormask technology

 

Choose Huggies Little Movers Slip-On Diaper Pants if you prefer:

  • Superabsorbent wood fluff pulp core
  • Leak Lock System
  • Pull-ups free from natural rubber latex, chlorine, lotion, and fragrance
  • Huggies’ SizeUp indicator that can help you determine if your baby needs to wear the next size

 

Choose Huggies Pull-Ups Training Pants if you prefer:

  • Hypoallergenic
  • Soft, refastenable sides
  • Pull-up diapers marketed as clinically proven to be hypoallergenic
  • Gender-based protection to ensure added absorbency at parts where boys or girls need most 
  • Underwear-like diapers for big kids

 

Choose Huggies Pull-Ups New Leaf if you prefer:

  • Plant-based material
  • Hypoallergenic
  • Pull-ups marketed as clinically proven to be hypoallergenic
  • Cute Disney prints

 

Choose Honest Company Toddler Training Pants if you prefer:

  • Sustainably harvested wood pulp and plant-derived materials
  • Pull-ups free from chlorine
  • Liquid-locking core with secure-fitting moisture barrier cuffs

 

Choose Bambo Nature Dream Training Pants if you prefer:

  • Certified eco-friendly pull-ups with TCF (totally chlorine-free) wood pulp
  • Certified skin-safe
  • Pull-ups free from harmful chemicals or allergens
  • Subscription options

 

Choose Parent’s Choice by Walmart Training Pants if you prefer: 

  • Budget-friendly diapers (smallest size: $0.27 per diaper; biggest size: $0.36 per diaper)
  • Pull-ups marketed to absorb up to 10x its own weight
  • Cute designs

 

Choose Up & Up by Target if you prefer:

  • Polypropylene, cloth-like cover
  • Elastic stretch sides with reclosable velcro
  • Underwear-like fit
  • Printed patterns (choices available for boys and girls)
  • Much lower prices than pull-ups from leading name brands (smallest size: $0.29 per diaper; biggest size: $0.42 per diaper)

 

Choose Thirsties Reusable Cloth Potty Training Pant if you prefer:

  • Reusable potty training pants
  • Bigger sizes (the biggest size can fit 42-56+ lbs)
  • Organic cotton absorbent layer, with a polyester outer layer
  • GOTS certified organic cotton, a certification for organic products free from toxic chemicals (3)
  • Wet zone with waterproof TPU (thermoplastic polyurethane) laminate that may help keep your baby’s clothes dry
  • Machine washable pull-ups

 

Choose MooMoo Kow Baby Potty Training Pants if you prefer:

  • Reusable training underwear
  • One size fits all (for 3-5 years old)
  • Soft bamboo with absorbent padding and waterproof outer layer
  • Thinner pull-ups than other cloth diapers
  • With adjustable snaps so your pull-ups can grow with your baby
  • Machine washable
  • Dryer safe or hung to dry
  • Cute prints

 

Choose Charlie Banana Training Pants With Snaps if you prefer:

  • Budget-friendly reusable training pants (smallest size: $12.99; biggest size: $14.99)
  • Waterproof outer cover with organic cotton inner lining
  • Cute prints
  • Climate Neutral Certified pull-ups
  • Machine washable

 

Factors To Consider In Choosing Pull-Ups

  • Non-toxic
  • Hypoallergenic
  • Absorbency
  • Durable but comfortable
  • Stretchy sides
  • Good fit
  • Leak control (legs, through diaper, or upper body)
  • Tear-away sides
  • Informative label
  • Eco-friendly
  • Price

 

FAQs

What Are The Most Absorbent Pull-Ups?

These pull-ups may be more absorbent than others:

  • Pampers Easy Ups Training Pants
  • Huggies Little Movers Slip-On Diaper Pants
  • Rascal + Friends Premium Training Pants
  • GoodNites Bedtime Pants

 

Do Pull-Ups Hold More Pee Than Diapers?

In general, pull-ups are less absorbent than diapers. They’re designed to help your child transition to underwear. By using pull-ups, your little one can be more aware of wetness, which may be more effective in potty training.

 

When Should I Use Pull-Ups Instead Of Diapers? 

Pull-ups don’t have wide-grip tabs like regular diapers. They can be ideal for use in older children who already know or may be interested in how to pull it up and down.

 

What Is The Pampers Version Of Pull-Ups? 

Pampers has the following pull-up diaper products:

  • Pampers Easy Ups Training Pants
  • Pampers Ninjamas
  • Pampers Under Jams (discontinued)

 

What’s The Biggest Size Pull-Ups? 

GoodNites Bedtime Pants have X-large pull-ups that may fit a child or an adult weighing 95 to 140 lbs.

 

How Can I Get Free Pull-Ups?

Pull-ups aren’t usually included in the hospital care package that you might receive after your baby’s birth. But you can still get some free samples through the following:

  • Request the brand for free samples (through their website or social media page)
  • Join a brand’s loyalty program
  • Visit a diaper bank
  • Find coupons
  • Free samples from stores
  • Ask pediatrician
  • Create a baby registry

 

 

 

REFERENCES

(1) https://www.oeko-tex.com/en/apply-here/standard-100-by-oeko-tex

(2) https://www.v-label.eu/faq

(3) https://global-standard.org/the-standard/gots-key-features/organic-fibres

 

 

 

as seen on
We Got You, Mama.

Self-Care Rituals & Self-Love Practices To Support You & Your Family.

[gravityform id="6" title="false" description="false" ajax="true"]